Chapter 1: Why a Chosen Nation, section 6 of 7 Overview of chapter 1 Book contents Previous Next

Five Stages of a Test

If we understand the events in Eden as man’s loss of instinct, then what follows makes eminent sense.

Notice first that the five sins progress from the gravest wrong to lesser and lesser ones. Murder is worse than adultery. Taking another man’s wife is worse than taking his possessions. Theft is worse than harmful testimony; perhaps not always in its consequences, but certainly as a moral wrong, since theft harms its victim directly, while testimony harms only indirectly, and not always. And harmful testimony is certainly worse than merely coveting what belongs to someone else. Notice too that the first three sins are acts, the fourth is a sin of speech, and the fifth is a sin of the mind. The progression moves from deed, to word, to thought.

What seems to have happened is this.

After Eden, man no longer had instinct to guide him. God expected that man would nonetheless be sensible enough to understand that murder is wrong. Nor was he left entirely without instruction. Jewish tradition holds that God taught Adam certain basic rules of conduct, including the prohibitions of murder, sexual immorality, and theft (Sanhedrin 56b). The period that followed was, in essence, a test of humanity. Could man, without instinct and with only this minimal guidance, behave in ways that were proper and beneficial? If so, the damage done in Eden could be repaired. If not, other steps would have to be taken for God’s plan for mankind to be fulfilled.

Cain, the son of Adam, failed the test. God warned him before he acted: “If you do well, will it not be lifted up? and if you do not do well, sin crouches at the door; and to you is its desire, but you may rule over it” (Genesis 4:7). But his anger and disappointment overcame him, and he killed his brother. For this he was banished from the presence of God, made unfit to take part directly in achieving the ultimate goal. The line that would lead to that goal passed instead through Seth, “another seed instead of Abel” (4:25).

Later generations may have learned that murder is wrong. But they did not grasp that adultery and theft are wrong as well, though these too are wrongs a person ought to understand without being told. When the earth became filled with these sins, there was no longer any hope that mankind as it then existed would achieve what was intended, and all of mankind was destroyed, except for Noah and his family.

Something similar nearly happened to Israel after the sin of the golden calf. Israel had been given a mission, and the calf was the very opposite of that mission. God was prepared to begin again: “leave Me alone, that My wrath may grow hot against them, and that I may consume them; and I will make of you a great nation” (Exodus 32:10). The new nation would have come from Moses, himself a descendant of Abraham, so that the promise to Abraham, that his descendants would bring about the final goal of creation, would still have been kept.

After the flood, mankind’s sins were no longer so gross. Noah and his sons understood that one must not murder, commit adultery, or steal. But the next step was not clear to all. It is not enough for people to refrain from harming one another; they are also expected to help one another. Ham failed in this. Where his brothers covered their father, he spoke of his father’s shame. He too was cut off from direct participation in achieving the goal: Noah cursed Ham’s son Canaan and blessed the two sons who had helped, Shem and Japheth. It is from Shem that Abraham would eventually descend.

Finally, the tower of Babel showed that mankind had failed even the last and most subtle stage of proper behavior: not even to desire what is not one’s own. Because this sin was subtle, and because mankind was then living in a degree of harmony, the punishment was not as severe as the flood. Mankind was not destroyed but dispersed. Yet because all of mankind took part in the sin, all hope was lost that mankind as a whole would achieve the goal directly.

A New Plan

A new plan had to be put in place. Instead of expecting all of mankind to reach the goal on its own, God would create a single nation that would accept His law and serve as an example of what human behavior ought to be.

This explains why the laws of the second tablet match the sins of the early generations. The laws were not written to commemorate those historical events. Rather, the laws and the events reflect the same underlying reality. The five laws represent five stages of proper behavior, progressing from the regulation of the most severe wrongs to the most subtle. The early history of mankind followed the same pattern because each failure was a failure at the next stage.

It seems that God would cut off an individual, or mankind as a whole, only for the gravest kind of wrong still being committed. Once He had made clear to Cain, and through him to all mankind, that murder is wrong, the hope was that no further wrongs of that kind would be done. Each time sin was followed by consequence, the next stage became the testing ground. In the end, mankind showed that it was not fit to work directly toward the final goal, and the new plan had to be put in place.

Last revised 10 November 2026