Chapter 2: The Purpose of Creation, section 3 of 7 Overview of chapter 2 Book contents Previous Next

Eden on Earth

According to Jewish tradition, had man not sinned he would have lived forever, and the purpose of creation would have been achieved here on earth. Nachmanides, commenting on Genesis 2:17, writes that man was created to live forever, and that death came only as a consequence of the sin. Man would have lived on in an earthly Eden, coming to know God in this world. (Whether such a thing is possible at all is a question I will take up in a later chapter.)

But once death and evil entered the world, an everlasting reward in this world was no longer possible. The focus shifted to a spiritual Gan Eden, where the soul lives on and receives its reward.

It is remarkable, then, that the Torah never describes such a spiritual world of reward. At most, tradition finds hints of it, in expressions such as being “gathered to his people” (Genesis 25:8) and in the sages’ interpretations of particular verses (Sanhedrin 90b). The rest of the Hebrew Bible says little more. Where it does speak of life after death, as in Daniel’s vision that “many of those who sleep in the dust of the earth will awake” (Daniel 12:2), it speaks of resurrection: a return to life, not a heaven above it.

The great Jewish thinkers of the Middle Ages noticed this silence and sought to explain it. Maimonides (Laws of Repentance 9:1), Nachmanides, and Joseph Albo all asked why the Torah’s promises concern rain, harvests, peace, and long life, rather than the world to come. Whatever the explanation, the fact itself is clear. Throughout the Torah, the reward for good deeds is blessing in this world. And the great prophecies of the future describe a time of blessedness on this earth.

So although the focus has in one sense shifted, the ultimate aim remains a blessed world here on earth. All of history moves toward that end: a world in which all mankind lives in harmony and peace, with justice and righteousness for all; a world in which the knowledge of God fills the earth, and all mankind comes to know God and to be grateful to Him for life itself and for the opportunity to know Him.

The Messianic Goal

As we saw in the previous chapter, mankind failed to reach this goal on its own, and a single nation was chosen to lead the way toward the era generally called “messianic,” in which the purpose of creation will be achieved.

The Torah contains hints of this future. Moses foretells Israel’s return to God and to its land (Deuteronomy 30:1–10), and Balaam sees “a star out of Jacob” (Numbers 24:17), passages Maimonides cites as the Torah’s own testimony to the messianic age (Laws of Kings 11:1). But the vision is expressed far more fully, and in vivid terms, in the prophetic books.

Thus, even if the ultimate reward is reserved for a spiritual world, the original aim of an Eden on earth remains, at least in part, within reach. History will not be complete until all mankind, here on earth, fulfills its purpose and reaches the stage foretold by the prophets.

Last revised 14 November 2026