Knowing God
The previous chapter spoke again and again of a goal, a plan for mankind that the chosen nation was meant to carry forward. What is that goal? What is the ultimate aim of creation, and how does the story of Eden fit into it? Parts of the answer have already appeared, but the question deserves a fuller treatment of its own.
First, notice something crucial. Man’s original home is called the garden of Eden, Gan Eden. In Jewish tradition, Gan Eden is also the name of the place where the righteous receive their everlasting reward in the world to come. This is obviously not a coincidence. But what does it mean?
To answer this, we must turn to Jewish philosophy, which has dealt with these questions directly, even if it has not applied its answers to the events of Eden in quite the way I am about to.
According to traditional Jewish thought, the entire purpose of creation is to give man the opportunity to know God. That is the greatest good one can ever achieve; no greater reward is possible.1 Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto, in The Way of God (Derech Hashem), explains that God, being good, created the world in order to bestow good, and that the true good is God Himself. But to receive that good fully, man must in some measure resemble Him. And so God made man master of his own perfection, able to earn it by his own choices rather than receive it as an unearned gift.
Consider an analogy. We can teach computers to behave like people; in some respects they already do things better than we do. But as far as we can tell, a computer does not know what it is to be human. Whatever it can do, it lacks the inner experience that makes us what we are.
Our relationship to God is similar. We cannot truly know God, because He is the Creator and we are created, and that alone is a gap we cannot cross. To know God in any sense possible for us, we must ourselves become, in some measure, creators. The gap must be closed, at least a little. To this end God gave us free choice: the ability to be our own masters, to shape ourselves and the world around us, to create our own destiny. Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik made a similar point in Halakhic Man: man fulfills his highest calling when he becomes a creator, first of all of himself.
But the ability to choose requires a choice that actually has to be made, with real consequences. Good choices must lead to good results, and bad choices to the opposite.
The Test in Eden
In Eden, man was given only one choice. Every tree was permitted except one. Why forbid that one? Because by refraining from it, man would acknowledge that he was created by God. His restraint would be a declaration of submission to God’s will, a recognition of his dependence on God, and by implication an expression of gratitude to the One who had created him. To eat would mean the opposite: ingratitude, an assertion of independence, a declaration that “I am free to do as I please.”
It was a simple test. Acknowledge God, and be grateful for the opportunity to know Him through His creation and all that is in it. Or go your own way and do as you please. But if you go your own way, everything will change. You will be thrown into a world of good and evil, a world of life and death.
This was no game. It was serious, because life is serious, because God is serious, because the choice was serious. Everything depended on it. For a reward of the magnitude being offered, the choice had to be real, momentous, transformative.
The first chapter of Genesis repeats a refrain as it describes creation: “And God saw that it was good.” It appears five times, and at the end, a sixth: “behold, it was very good” (1:31). The universe was created to be good. Evil enters only in chapters 2 and 3, with the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. The tree is called that not because its fruit had magical powers, but because that is what the choice it represented necessarily was. Near the end of the Torah, Moses puts the same choice before Israel in almost the same terms:
See, I have set before you this day life and good, and death and evil… I have set before you life and death, the blessing and the curse; therefore choose life. (Deuteronomy 30:15, 19)
The choice in Eden was the same: good and life, or evil and death.
Notice, too, what the serpent told Eve: “you will be like God, knowing good and evil” (Genesis 3:5). In a sense this was true. To eat was to declare independence from God, to become one’s own master, to pretend that one is like a god and that the whole world is one’s own. And in a sense man received what he asked for. Having declared his independence, he was left to govern himself, without the God-given inner guidance that instinct had provided. Instinct was torn from him and he was left on his own, to choose, to make a world of good or a world of evil. Without instinct, he turned inward, preoccupied mainly with himself, not concerned with others. For that reason, relationship with others became a challenge that had to be overcome, and laws had to be created to harness his impulses. He was on his own, free to reshape the world as he saw fit, but not without consequence. Bad choices would lead to death and curse, good choices to life and blessing.
-
Stephen Hawking (1942–2018), the Cambridge physicist renowned for his work on black holes and the origin of the universe, ended his best-selling A Brief History of Time (1988) by imagining a complete theory that would explain why the universe exists at all. Finding it, he wrote, would be the ultimate triumph of human reason, “for then we would know the mind of God.” Hawking was not a believer. He later explained that he meant the phrase figuratively, and in The Grand Design (2010, with Leonard Mlodinow) he argued that the universe needs no Creator to explain it. It is all the more striking, then, that when he sought words for the highest achievement the human mind could attain, he described it as knowing God. ↩