The Purpose of Exile
Why should the sins of one generation lead to a decree affecting all future generations? What follows is my own suggestion; I know of no source that states it in this form.
Moses speaks about the future with complete certainty. Twice, in Deuteronomy 4 and again in chapter 31, he declares that the nation will eventually turn to idols. The Torah even gives Israel a song, the song of Ha’azinu, so that when disaster comes they will remember that they were warned: “this song will testify before them as a witness” (Deuteronomy 31:21). And he explains why he is so certain:
For I know your rebellion, and your stiff neck; behold, while I am still alive with you this day, you have been rebellious against the LORD; and how much more after my death? (31:27)
The inability of the first generation to keep the law fully meant that later generations, too, would very likely fail. And if the nation could not become the example it was meant to be, the plan could not work as first intended. The chosen nation was to be “high above all nations… in praise, and in name, and in glory” (26:19), a people the world would admire and wish to emulate. A nation that repeatedly strayed could not fill that role, at least not in its own land.
But there was another way. Exile is not only a punishment; it is also a means of reaching the goal. It works in two ways.
First, exile spread the knowledge of God. It is a historical fact that belief in one God reached much of the world because of the dispersion of the Jews, especially during and after the Second Temple period. By the first century, Jewish communities were found throughout the Roman Empire and beyond, and many non-Jews were drawn to them. Some converted; many more, known as “God-fearers,” attended synagogues and adopted Jewish practices. Ancient writers noticed with some alarm. Josephus boasted that there was hardly a city where Jewish customs such as the Sabbath were not observed. The Roman philosopher Seneca complained that the conquered had given their laws to their conquerors. Will Durant, in The Story of Civilization, describes the extent of this attraction to Judaism in the Roman world.
Christianity spread first along these same paths. The apostles preached in synagogues across the Diaspora, and their earliest gentile followers came largely from among the God-fearers who had already learned of the God of Israel from the Jews. Islam, too, arose in a region with established Jewish communities and drew deeply on Jewish tradition.
Maimonides saw the meaning of this. Christianity and Islam, he wrote, serve to prepare the way for the Messiah and to bring the whole world to serve God together. Through them the world has been filled with talk of the Messiah, of the Torah, and of the commandments, so that when the Messiah comes, the nations will be ready to understand (Laws of Kings 11:4).
The Talmud states the principle directly: the Holy One exiled Israel among the nations only so that converts would join them (Pesachim 87b). Exile carried the knowledge of God to places it would otherwise never have reached.
Second, exile made Israel an example of another kind. Moses warned that in exile Israel would become “an astonishment, a proverb, and a byword, among all the peoples to which the LORD will lead you away” (Deuteronomy 28:37). And he foretold that the nations would look at the ruined land and ask what had happened:
All the nations will say: “Why has the LORD done so to this land? what is the meaning of the heat of this great anger?” Then men will say: “Because they forsook the covenant of the LORD, the God of their fathers…” (29:23–24)
If the nation would not be an example to follow, it would become an example from which others learned. Scattered among the nations, Israel would teach the world in two ways at once: positively, through its faith and its law, wherever it was faithful; and negatively, through the consequences of its failures, which the nations themselves would recognize.
Even the suffering of the Jewish people has, in some measure, taught the world. The Holocaust revealed the depths to which hatred can lead with a clarity no generation before had seen. Lucy Dawidowicz, in The War Against the Jews (1975), argued that the destruction of the Jews was not a side effect of the Second World War but one of its central aims. In the war’s aftermath the nations adopted the Genocide Convention (the word “genocide” was coined by Raphael Lemkin, himself a Jew who lost most of his family in the Holocaust) and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, both in 1948. The world learned, at terrible cost, where hatred of the Jews and of others leads, although it is not necessarily a lesson that has remained with its full force since then.