Chapter 3: Failure and Exile, section 1 of 2 Overview of chapter 3 Book contents Previous Next

Why the Goal Was Not Reached

Several questions remain. The first is perhaps the most obvious: if this was the plan, why has the goal not yet been reached? What happened?

According to Jewish tradition, the goal could have been achieved soon after Israel entered the land of Canaan. Had the people fully kept the laws given to them, they would have become a kingdom of priests at once, and this would in time have led to the messianic age. The Talmud expresses this in a striking way: had Israel not sinned, they would have been given only the five books of the Torah and the book of Joshua (Nedarim 22b). The rest of the Bible, the long record of prophetic rebuke and warning, would never have been needed.

But Israel did not fully keep the law. Almost immediately after receiving it, the people sinned with the golden calf. Later, when Moses sent spies to scout the land, they sinned again. The spies returned with a discouraging report, the people lost faith that they could take the land, and they wanted to return to Egypt.

God’s response was that the generation that had left Egypt would not enter the land. “Your carcasses will fall in this wilderness” (Numbers 14:29); only their children would enter. This consequence resembles those we have seen before. Adam and Eve were driven out of Eden. Cain was banished from the presence of God. The builders of Babel were scattered across the earth. Here too the consequence was a kind of banishment: exclusion from the land.

More important, the consequence did not fall only on those who sinned. It changed the plan once again. The Psalmist, recalling the spies, says:

Moreover, they scorned the desirable land, they did not believe His word; but they murmured in their tents, they did not listen to the voice of the LORD. Therefore He swore concerning them, that He would overthrow them in the wilderness; and that He would cast out their seed among the nations, and scatter them in the lands. (Psalm 106:24–27)

Ezekiel says the same: “I lifted up My hand to them in the wilderness, that I would scatter them among the nations, and disperse them through the countries” (Ezekiel 20:23). The sin in the wilderness led to a decree that the nation would one day be exiled from its land and scattered among the nations. The Talmud connects the two events directly. The night the people wept after hearing the spies’ report was the ninth of Av, and God said: you wept for nothing; I will give you a reason to weep for generations (Taanit 29a). The ninth of Av became the day on which both Temples were destroyed.

The failure of that first generation thus transformed the whole course of Israel’s history. The messianic age had to be postponed. There would now be settlement in the land, then exile, and only at the end a final return to the land and the coming of the messianic age.

The Torah foretells both the exile and the return explicitly, more than once. “And I will scatter you among the nations” (Leviticus 26:33; see also Deuteronomy 4:27, 28:64). And then: “the LORD your God will turn your captivity, and have compassion upon you, and will return and gather you from all the peoples, among whom the LORD your God has scattered you” (Deuteronomy 30:3).

The Torah also tells us when this return will come. Moses says: “In your distress, when all these things have come upon you, in the end of days, you will return to the LORD your God, and listen to His voice” (Deuteronomy 4:30). The phrase “the end of days,” acharit ha-yamim, implies that history would now unfold over a very long period. And it is exactly the phrase with which Isaiah opens the vision quoted earlier: “And it will come to pass in the end of days that the mountain of the LORD’s house will be established as the top of the mountains, and all nations will flow to it” (Isaiah 2:2). The return foretold by Moses and the peace foretold by Isaiah belong to the same final stage of history.

Last revised 11 November 2026