Four Stages of Jewish History
If we take a broader view, we find the same pattern in the whole course of Jewish history.
That history can be divided into four stages. First, the period of the Torah itself. Second, the period recorded in the books of Joshua, Judges, Samuel, and Kings, the Former Prophets, which carry Israel’s history from its entry into the land to the destruction of the First Temple. Third, a period of exile. And fourth, a period not yet reached: the messianic era.
These four stages correspond to four of the five books of the Torah, all but Leviticus. The absence of a stage corresponding to Leviticus explains itself. Leviticus is the book of the present, “keep My covenant,” the book of law. The law was given once, and the Torah states explicitly that nothing may be added to it or taken from it: “You shall not add to the word which I command you, nor shall you diminish from it” (Deuteronomy 4:2). The sages concluded that no prophet may introduce new commandments (Shabbat 104a). The giving of the law happened once and could never happen again, so there can be no later period that repeats it.
One might argue that the Second Temple period should count as a separate stage. In a sense it should, but in reality it was still a period of exile. Many Jews never returned to the land; they remained scattered among other nations. The Temple itself fell far short of the first. The Talmud lists five things present in the First Temple that were missing from the Second, among them the ark of the covenant, which held the tablets of stone (Yoma 21b). For most of the period, the nation lived under the rule of foreign powers: Persia, the Greek kingdoms, and finally Rome. Its own leaders said as much. Ezra, praying in Jerusalem, called his people “slaves,” for “in our bondage our God has not forsaken us” (Ezra 9:9), and the Levites in Nehemiah’s day declared, “behold, we are servants this day… in the land that Thou gave to our fathers” (Nehemiah 9:36). There was a return to the land, but the exile had not ended.
A Period of Law
The actual history, then, has four stages, not five. There is no stage of law, because no new law was given. Yet the history does contain a hint of such a stage, early in the period that corresponds to Numbers, the period of exile.
It was during the Second Temple period that the Oral Law took the form we know today. The tractate Avot, which traces the chain of sages who transmitted the Oral Law, begins its list of individual names with Shimon the Righteous, who lived early in the Second Temple period, and continues without a break to the generation that completed the Mishnah. This implies that throughout the Second Temple period the Oral Law was taking its final shape.
I do not mean that the Oral Law originated then, or that the laws themselves were created then. But the troubles the nation constantly endured made it necessary to set the tradition in a form that would preserve it, even when times were bad. The Talmud itself notes that disputes multiplied in the generation of the disciples of Hillel and Shammai (Sanhedrin 88b). The period opened, moreover, with a public renewal of the covenant: Ezra read the law to the assembled people, and they bound themselves by a written pledge to keep it (Nehemiah 8–10).
So within the early part of the exile there was a period devoted to law: not a distinct era, since nothing new was given, but an effort to preserve the law correctly. There is, after all, a stage that corresponds to Leviticus, if not in full, then at least in part.
The full correspondence, then, is this:
- Genesis is the background to the nation’s history. The period of the Torah is the background to all of Israel’s later history.
- Exodus tells of the nation’s development and the establishment of its institutions. The period of the Former Prophets shows the nation in its fullest form: living within its own borders, with all its national institutions in place. The parallel extends even to the language. Exodus ends with the completion of the Tabernacle: “the glory of the LORD filled the tabernacle. And Moses was not able to enter” (Exodus 40:34–35). At the dedication of Solomon’s Temple, “the priests could not stand to minister because of the cloud; for the glory of the LORD filled the house of the LORD” (1 Kings 8:11).
- Leviticus is the book of law. There was no separate era of law, but early in the exile, during the Second Temple period, the law took its lasting form through the Oral Tradition.
- Numbers tells of the nation’s years of wandering in the wilderness, in effect a long exile from the land it was meant to enter. The present exile corresponds to it. And it was in Numbers, with the sin of the spies, that the decree of exile was first set in motion.
- Deuteronomy is the book of the goal: how to become a kingdom of priests. The messianic era will be the fulfillment of that goal.
The Former Prophets
It is of interest that the Former Prophets also consist of four books: Joshua, Judges, Samuel, and Kings. We are not yet ready to examine this with care, and we may return to it after we have seen other parallels to the books of the Torah. But even now some correspondences can be detected, though they cannot yet be fully developed.
Joshua. The first book contains the background for this era, the era in which Israel was a nation in its own land. Its focus is the conquest of the land, which sets the stage for everything that follows. In this it resembles Genesis, which serves as the background for the creation of the nation and for all that follows in the Torah, which is about the nation itself. The book even ends the way Genesis ends. Joshua, before his death, reviews the history of the patriarchs, beginning with Terach (Joshua 24:2–4). He dies at the age of one hundred and ten, as Joseph did (Joshua 24:29; Genesis 50:26). And the book closes with the burial of Joseph’s bones at Shechem, fulfilling the oath Joseph exacted at the end of Genesis (Joshua 24:32; Genesis 50:25).
Judges. The book of Judges describes an early stage in the nation’s life in its land. Its link to Exodus is not obvious on the surface. But when we look at it more carefully later on, we will see that its events parallel, and at times almost mimic, events recounted in Exodus. The very name of the period, the age of the judges, also links it to that book, as will be explained more fully when we discuss the themes of the books.
Samuel. The relationship of Samuel to Numbers is the least clear of the four. We will leave it for now, since it requires tools we will shortly begin to develop.
Kings. The last book’s overarching subject, kings and kingdom, links it to Deuteronomy and to the messianic era. The nation is to be a “kingdom of priests,” and the messianic era centers on a future king descended from the house of David. Notably, the only law in the Torah concerning a king appears in Deuteronomy (17:14–20). For now the link may seem somewhat superficial, but as we continue we will see that kingship is a central feature of the final stage.