Self-Similarity
What we have seen so far is a grand view: the whole of Jewish history, and two of its eras. The structure of each era, the era of the Torah and the era of the Former Prophets, follows the same pattern as the history of the nation as a whole. The whole of history consists of four major eras. The Torah consists of five stages, because it contains an additional stage of law, but its other four stages follow the same pattern. The era of the Former Prophets likewise consists of four parts that parallel the four eras of history as a whole. Not every part of the correlation has yet been worked out, but this is the scheme being proposed.
This kind of structure has a striking parallel in the modern understanding of nature. Mathematicians call it self-similarity, and it is the defining feature of what are called fractals.
The term was coined in 1975 by the mathematician Benoit Mandelbrot. A fractal is a shape in which each part resembles the whole. Look closely at any piece, and you find the same structure again; look closely at a piece of that piece, and you find it yet again, at smaller and smaller scales.
Mandelbrot’s great insight was that nature is full of such shapes. A fern is the classic example: each frond is a small copy of the whole fern, and each leaflet on the frond is a smaller copy still. A tree’s trunk divides into branches, the branches into smaller branches, and those into twigs, each division following the same pattern. Rivers gather their tributaries the same way, and the tributaries gather theirs. A head of Romanesco broccoli is made of cones, each made of smaller cones, each made of smaller ones still. A coastline seen from an airplane has the same jagged irregularity as the same coastline seen at ground level. Lightning branches the way rivers do. Inside our own bodies, the airways of the lungs divide again and again, as do the blood vessels, packing an enormous surface into a small space. Even the stock market shows it: Mandelbrot found that a chart of price movements over years looks much like a chart of movements over days.
Fractals are not a curiosity of mathematics. They are one of nature’s fundamental ways of building things. And in nature, fractal structures typically arise from a single simple rule applied over and over: a branch splits, and each new branch follows the same rule. The self-similarity we see is the visible signature of that one underlying rule at work.
This is precisely what I am proposing about the Torah and Jewish history. The same pattern appears at the scale of the nation’s entire history, at the scale of the Torah, at the scale of the Former Prophets, and, as we saw, in the cycle of the holidays. If the pattern is real, it suggests not an accumulation of independent pieces assembled over centuries, but a single design governing the whole. If so, the Torah is built the way the world itself is built.
Of course, human beings are very good at finding patterns, sometimes where none exist. A mathematical fractal is defined precisely; a pattern in a text is a matter of interpretation. The reader is right to demand that each correspondence be stated clearly and checked carefully, and I will try to do so, acknowledging where a correspondence is incomplete.
A Fractal Picture in Jewish Thought
The idea itself is not new to Jewish thought. In Kabbalah, the Jewish mystical tradition, God’s relationship to the world is described through ten sefirot, attributes or channels through which God’s presence flows into creation: wisdom, understanding, kindness, judgment, beauty, and so on. A central principle of Kabbalah is that each sefirah contains within it all ten. Kindness contains its own wisdom, its own judgment, and the rest; and each of those in turn contains all ten again, without end. The sixteenth-century kabbalist Rabbi Moses Cordovero developed this principle systematically. Many Jews encounter it every year without realizing it. During the seven weeks between Passover and the Feast of Weeks, each day of the counting of the Omer is associated with a combination of two sefirot: “kindness within kindness,” “judgment within kindness,” and so on, forty-nine combinations in all. Whatever one makes of the kabbalists’ claims, their picture of reality is unmistakably fractal: the whole is present in every part, and the pattern repeats at every level.
So far we have been zooming out, looking at the largest scale. Let us now look in the other direction. Instead of zooming out, let us zoom in. How are the details of the Torah organized? Do they, too, correspond in some way to the structure of the Torah as a whole?
We will begin with the book of Genesis, which provides one of the clearest and best examples of this principle.