Chapter 5: Self-Similarity and the Structure of Genesis, section 3 of 5 Overview of chapter 5 Book contents Previous Next

The Torah’s Own Divisions

Where exactly each of the five parts of Genesis begins and ends will be shown shortly. For now, it is enough to say that the boundaries are not arbitrary; they are marked by the Torah itself. It will become clear, for example, that the binding of Isaac belongs to Isaac’s story, not Abraham’s.

Something similar can be shown for each book of the Torah: each divides naturally into five parts. We will look at some of these later. But first I want to show that the structure we are exploring goes further still. The stories of Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, and Joseph are each told in exactly five units of text.

This requires some explanation. What is meant by a “unit of text”?

To understand how material in the Torah is organized, one must use the Torah’s own system of organizing it. Most readers today know the Bible through its chapters and verses. The verses are ancient. But the chapter divisions are a late invention, imposed on the text from outside. They were devised around the year 1200 by Stephen Langton, later Archbishop of Canterbury, for the Latin Bible, and entered printed Hebrew Bibles only centuries later. Where the topical boundaries are obvious, the chapters often fall in the right places, but very often they are completely off.

Even the division of the Torah into weekly portions, the parashiyot read in the synagogue each Sabbath, is not part of the text itself. It has far more claim than the chapters to reflecting genuine breaks in the text; it may go back to the distant past and can be regarded as part of the Oral Tradition. But the weekly portions were designed for reading, not to mark the flow of the material, and often they do not.

Open and Closed Breaks

The Torah has its own system of divisions, written into the text itself. In a Torah scroll, the text is not written continuously. At certain points the scribe leaves a blank space. There are two kinds:

  • A petuchah, an “open” break: the scribe leaves the rest of the line blank and begins the next passage at the start of a new line.
  • A setumah, a “closed” break: the scribe leaves a gap in the middle of the line, roughly the width of nine letters, and continues on the same line.

The open break is visually much larger than the closed one, and it marks a larger division of the text. The closed break marks a smaller division within it. In all, the Torah contains about 290 open breaks and 379 closed ones.

These breaks are not decoration, and they are not a matter of the scribe’s discretion. Their placement is fixed by Jewish law: a Torah scroll in which an open break is written as a closed one, or a closed break as an open one, or in which a break is added or omitted, is invalid and may not be used. Maimonides lists every one of them in his code (Laws of Torah Scrolls, chapter 8). They are ancient as well; the biblical scrolls found among the Dead Sea Scrolls divide their text in a similar way. And the sages understood them as intrinsic to the text from the beginning. The Midrash explains that the breaks were there to give Moses pause to reflect between one section and the next (Sifra, cited by Rashi on Leviticus 1:1).

For the purposes of this book, a section is the text from one open break to the next. The closed breaks within it divide the section into subsections. In what follows I will almost always analyze the structure of the Torah in terms of sections. The subsections are the next level down, and we will only very occasionally look at them too, since the pattern, as far as I can tell, rarely appears there.

Last revised 11 November 2026