Chapter 19: Long-Distance Connections: Other Books, section 5 of 5 Overview of chapter 19 Book contents Previous Next

Conclusion

We have now looked at six books of the Bible: Judges, Samuel, Ruth, Ecclesiastes, Psalms and Isaiah. Each of them alludes to the Torah, and between them they reach every part of it. Judges alone links to Genesis, Exodus, Numbers and Deuteronomy: to the story of Sodom, the parting of the Sea, the giving of the Torah at Sinai, the trumpets and the war against Midian, the Nazirite, and the laws of Deuteronomy 6, 7 and 20. Samuel links to the laws of Exodus 22. Ruth is built on a law in Deuteronomy 23. Ecclesiastes is built on the law of hakhel in Deuteronomy 31, and through it reaches back to Sinai. Psalms opens with the last words of Moses. Isaiah opens with the Song of Ha’azinu, and then follows the first chapter of Deuteronomy.

I am sure there are more such books. I have not had the opportunity to look. It takes work, but anyone can do it, with a concordance or a good computer program. Look for phrases or words that are rare, or at least very uncommon. One such phrase or word is usually no indication of anything significant; it takes several before a pattern begins to emerge. Then see whether those words connect the passage to some other place, and think about whether anyone would have wanted to connect the two. If the second passage illuminates the first, if the later story reads differently once the earlier one is in mind, the connection is probably not an accident.

The direction of the connections. One feature of these links stands out. In my experience, the connections run from a later book back to the Torah.

There are, of course, places where one prophet says something similar to another. The best-known example is a passage that appears almost word for word in both Isaiah and Micah: “they shall beat their swords into plowshares” (Isa 2:2–4; Mic 4:1–3). But such parallels are explicit. They repeat a text openly, and the reason is easy to understand.

The connections we have looked at are of a different kind. They do not repeat the earlier text. They allude to it. They require the reader to know the earlier text very well. And their purpose is not to restate it but to suggest that what is being described now is a later appearance of something that already happened, or was already commanded, long before. Sisera’s defeat is a new crossing of the Sea. Gideon’s victory takes up the giving of the Torah at Sinai. Gibeah is Sodom again. The judges of Isaiah’s Jerusalem have betrayed the charge Moses gave to the first judges. This kind of writing makes sense only if the earlier text was regarded as the pattern for everything that came after it.

The nature of the allusions. Think, too, about how these allusions are made. They are not explicit, and often not even overt. They are subtle and nuanced, in some cases almost hidden. They are not noticed unless one stops to ask a question. Why is this word written in this odd way? Why does the name of this clan break the usual rule? Why does this angel call himself by this name? Why does this verb appear in the future tense when it speaks of the past? Allusions of this kind presume a reader who knows the earlier text so thoroughly that a single unusual word is enough to recall it. Otherwise they are wasted effort. An author does not hide references to a text his readers do not know.

What follows. Bible critics believe the Torah to be a late composition, assembled from several earlier sources and completed after many of the other books of the Bible were written. I do not know exactly how each school of criticism dates the Book of Judges relative to the Torah. But on the critical view, it seems almost certain that the author of Judges did not have the complete Torah before him. Yet the account of Gideon alone has multiple points of contact with passages scattered across four different books of the Torah.

Consider what the alternative would require. Someone would have had to compose the Torah later, and weave into it, across widely separated books, details that a reader of the Gideon story would recognize as its source. These would include a rare verb containing Gideon’s name, the single plene spelling of Gideoni, the Torah’s only use of the verb of blowing for an instrument, and the only other occurrence of an odd written form. And all of this would have been done while keeping the Torah readable and coherent in its own right. It is one thing for a later author to model his text on a single older text. It is quite another to suppose that a later text was composed to resemble the older books in many ways at once, so as to make it look like their source. That is hardly the natural assumption, and it violates Occam’s razor on its face.

Some scholars hold that the books from Joshua through Kings were edited by the same circle that produced Deuteronomy. If that were so, it might account for links between those books and Deuteronomy. It would not account for the links we found to Genesis, Exodus and Numbers: to Sodom, to the Song of the Sea, to the trumpets of Numbers 10, to the Nazirite law. Critics assign those passages to entirely different sources.

Not every example carries the same weight against the critical view. Some of the books we examined, such as Ruth and Ecclesiastes, are dated late by the critics themselves. For them, a Torah already in existence raises no difficulty. The force of the argument lies in the books that the critics date early, above all Judges and Samuel and the first chapter of Isaiah. It lies also in the way their links spread across what the critics regard as separate sources. And it lies in the pattern as a whole. The later books of the Bible, from every period, look back to the Torah in the same deliberate way, and they look to nothing else in that way.

Taken one at a time, each of these links might be questioned. The weight lies in the whole, and the whole makes the conclusion, to my mind, inescapable. The authors of the later books had before them a Torah that they regarded as extraordinarily special. When they described an event, or chose a word, they consciously connected their own writing to that earlier, sacred text. They did not borrow from it as one borrows from a source. They revered it, and they wrote so that their readers, who revered it too, would hear it behind every line.

Last revised 12 November 2026