Names without the Name
Critics often point to anachronisms, details that belong to a later age, as evidence that a book was written late. The divine names allow the argument to be turned around. The absence of anachronism, where it would be expected, points to early writing.
In the later books of the Bible, a great many personal names contain the divine name: Yehonatan, Yehoshafat, and Yo’ash at the beginning, and Yeshayahu (Isaiah), Yirmeyahu (Jeremiah), and Eliyahu (Elijah) at the end. In the Torah there is not a single such name.
The rule must be stated precisely. No personal name in the Torah contains enough letters of the divine name to be a divine name. The two letters Y-H, yod and he, do form a name of God: Yah. It appears twice in the Torah, both times in speech: in the Song at the Sea, “The LORD [Yah] is my strength and song” (Exod 15:2), and in Moses’ words after the battle with Amalek (17:16). The three letters Y-H-V form the beginning of the full name. Neither combination appears as a prefix or suffix in any name in the Torah. A single yod, or yod-vav, may hint at the name, as perhaps in Yocheved, but neither is a name. (In names such as Yosef, Yuval and Yovav, the yod-vav simply belongs to the root of the word.) Rabbinic law draws the same line independently: Yah is counted among the names of God that may not be erased, while no such status is given to a yod or yod-vav alone. And it is fitting that the one name in the Torah that may hint at the divine name belongs to the mother of Moses, the man to whom the name was revealed.
Only three names in the Torah, Yehudah, Yehudit and Yehoshua, begin with the letters Y-H-V, and all three are explained. In Yehudah (Judah) the letters H-V belong to the root, as Leah’s words at his birth make explicit: “This time I will praise the LORD” (Gen 29:35). Yehudit (Judith), the wife of Esau (Gen 26:34), bears a name formed from Yehudah, with the same root. Yehoshua was originally Hoshea, which already contained the H-V. The Torah records that Moses changed it: “And Moses called Hoshea the son of Nun Joshua” (Num 13:16). He added a single yod, the least addition that would bring the divine name to mind without writing it. The Torah thus records the first appearance of such a name, made by Moses himself after the name had been revealed to him.
A few other names contain the letters by chance, as part of different words. Avihu means “he is my father”; in it the yod belongs to avi, “my father,” and the H-V to hu, “he.” Ammihud and Achihud are built the same way. Ayah (Gen 36:24) is the name of a bird (Lev 11:14). In none of these is the divine name an element of the name.
Place names are a different matter. The land of Moriah, where Abraham was sent to bind Isaac (Gen 22:2), ends in the letters Y-H. It is not clear that the ending stands for the divine name, and the name has been explained in several ways. But even if it does, it is not unusual. On that same mountain Abraham named the place YHWH Yireh, “the LORD will see” (22:14). After the battle with Amalek, Moses built an altar and called it YHWH Nissi, “the LORD is my banner” (Exod 17:15). These are holy places, named for what God did there, and such names are fitting in any age, even the earliest. A personal name is different. It is borne by an ordinary person in everyday life, and it is there that the Torah never uses the divine name.
The positive evidence is just as striking. The lists of tribal leaders in Numbers are full of names built on El, such as Eliav, Elishama, Elitzur, Shelumiel, Netanel, Gamliel, Pagiel, and Elyasaf, and on Shaddai, such as Tzurishaddai and Ammishaddai. That matches what God says in Exodus 6:3: He appeared to the patriarchs as El Shaddai. Names containing the divine name begin to appear only occasionally in Joshua and Judges, as with Yo’ash, Yotam, and Michayehu. They become dominant only under the monarchy, as the inscriptions of that period confirm. The seals, the letters from Arad and Lachish, and the records from Samaria are full of names ending in -yahu and -yo.
The critics answer that a late writer who believed the name was unknown before Moses would have avoided such names on purpose, so the absence shows deliberate archaizing, not age. But the restriction holds in the material they assign to J as well, and J uses the name YHWH from the start, so its author had no theological reason to avoid such names. An author who policed names that carefully would also have had to keep it up across hundreds of names, without a single slip toward the forms he heard every day. And the gradual increase through Joshua, Judges, and the monarchy looks like a real historical development, not like one writer’s program.
The Evidence of Chronicles
The book of Chronicles adds an interesting complication. Its lists name a grandson of Moses, the son of Eliezer, as Rechavyah, and once as Rechavyahu, with the full three letters (1 Chr 23:17; 24:21). The same lists name Yechdeyahu, a later descendant of Moses (24:20). Chronicles also names a daughter of Pharaoh, Bityah (4:18), whom rabbinic tradition identifies with the woman who drew Moses out of the Nile (Megillah 13a). The Torah tells her story but never gives her name.
Either way, these names help the argument. If they are authentic, such names existed in the time of the Torah, and their absence from the Torah reflects a deliberate restraint in writing the divine name. That restraint is one consistent practice across the whole Torah, like the narrator’s rule. If the Chronicler, writing much later, gave the names their later forms, then he shows exactly the kind of anachronism the Torah lacks. Whatever the case may be, it is clear that in the period of the Torah such names were rare at most. A Torah written centuries later, in a world full of them, should have let some of them creep in.