Chapter 26: Long Lives and Creation, section 5 of 7 Overview of chapter 26 Book contents Previous Next

The Objections, and a Different Clock

Many readers will object to what has just been said, and their objections are serious.

The first is the Sabbath. The Torah links the Sabbath directly to the days of creation: “For in six days the LORD made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that is in them, and rested on the seventh day; therefore the LORD blessed the sabbath day, and hallowed it” (Exod 20:11). If the days of creation were periods of unknown length, the comparison seems to lose its force. Why should a week of seven ordinary days commemorate six stages that may each have lasted millions of years?

The second is Nachmanides. In his commentary on the creation account he states plainly that the days of creation were real days, made up of hours and minutes, just like the six working days of our week.

Because of objections like these, the physicist Gerald Schroeder, in his book Genesis and the Big Bang and its sequel, proposed a different approach, one that keeps the six days as days and draws on modern physics.

One of the most important consequences of Einstein’s theory of relativity is that time does not pass at the same rate everywhere. How fast a clock ticks depends on where it is and how it is moving. Two things in particular affect it. The first is speed: the faster an object moves, the more slowly time passes for it compared with an object at rest. At ordinary speeds the effect is tiny, but it is real and has been measured. At the speed of light it becomes total; in a sense, light does not experience the passage of time at all. No material object can reach that speed, but even matter experiences time differently according to how fast it travels. The second is gravity: the stronger the gravity, the more slowly time passes. A clock at sea level runs very slightly slower than one on a mountaintop. None of this is speculation. The satellites that make up the GPS navigation system carry precise clocks, and because those clocks move fast and sit far from the earth’s gravity, they run at a slightly different rate from clocks on the ground. Engineers must correct for the difference every day, or the system would soon be useless.

Schroeder’s proposal is that the six days of creation were measured by a different clock from the one we use on earth: a clock that, in effect, belongs to the universe as a whole from the moment of its beginning. Because the universe has been expanding ever since, a span of time that registered as six days on that cosmic clock corresponds, by Schroeder’s calculation, to roughly fifteen billion years as measured from the earth today. He works out the figures for each of the six days separately and finds that they match the sequence of events that science describes reasonably well. The author of this book cannot vouch for the accuracy of his calculations. But it is a serious suggestion, and Schroeder was not the first to make it in principle.

Some years earlier, Rabbi Shimon Schwab, in an essay published in Challenge, a volume issued by the Association of Orthodox Jewish Scientists in 1976, made a similar suggestion, though without the mathematics or the precision of Schroeder’s work. He pointed out that the fifth chapter of Genesis opens with the words “This is the book of the generations of Adam” (Gen 5:1). With these words, he suggested, a new era begins, one whose clock is linked to time as measured on earth. Before that, during the days of creation, a different clock was running. He did not appeal to Einstein or to the physics of time. He simply read the text as marking a change in how time is measured.

This answer may seem forced at first. But it fits well with two ideas that have deep roots in Jewish thought.

The first is that God does not exist in time. If, according to physics, a beam of light does not experience time, then surely God, who created light, does not either. Jewish thinkers have long held that time itself is part of creation. Maimonides writes that time is a feature of the physical world, which came into being with it (Guide of the Perplexed II:13). Time began “in the beginning,” together with heaven and earth. God, and spiritual beings generally, are not bound by it. When the Torah describes creation from God’s perspective, there is no reason to assume that its days are measured by a clock that did not yet exist.

The second is that the commentators themselves asked how time could have been measured during the first days of creation. The sun, which marks our days, was not set in its place until the fourth day. What, then, made the first three days days? The question was raised long before anyone had heard of relativity. To say that a different clock was operating then is not a modern evasion. It is an answer to a question the tradition itself had asked.

Last revised 14 November 2026