A Single Utterance, Many Kinds
One more point about the utterances of creation. When the Torah says that a single command of God brought forth a whole range of living things, “Let the waters swarm with swarms of living creatures, and let birds fly above the earth” (Gen 1:20), or “Let the earth bring forth the living creature after its kind, cattle, and creeping thing, and beast of the earth after its kind” (Gen 1:24), most people picture a magical scene, with countless creatures suddenly appearing all at once.
But notice how the Torah phrases these commands. It does not say, “Let there be fish,” or “Let there be cattle.” It says, “Let the waters swarm,” and “Let the earth bring forth.” God commands the waters and the earth to produce. Rashi, following the Midrash, goes further. He explains that everything was in fact created on the first day, and that on each later day these things only needed to be brought forth, each in its proper time (Rashi on Gen 1:14 and 1:24). On this reading the potential for every kind of life was present from the beginning, and each utterance drew it out.
If life developed over time, the picture is much the same. A single utterance would not have produced each creature individually. It would have set in motion a process, setting the conditions so that within what had been made lay the potential for a whole variety of kinds to emerge. One utterance, many kinds.
How such a thing could work is entirely unknown, and anything said about it is speculation. But it may be worth noting that the more closely one looks at how living things are built, the harder it becomes to see how the work could be done without some kind of built-in knowledge. Living things are assembled from parts that are reused, combined and rearranged, like modules in a well-designed system. Modularity of this kind makes little sense unless something in the cell, in whatever form, “knows” how the pieces fit together. If anything like that should turn out to be true, then one might say that this is what each utterance did: it triggered something within the living world that enabled a certain range of creatures to form, each “after its kind.”
This is no more than a suggestion. But it shows that the Torah’s account of creation by utterance need not be pictured as magic. It can just as well be understood as God setting in motion, at each turning point, a system capable of bringing forth a world full of life.
Unanswered Questions
This part of the book has not tried to answer every question one might raise about the Torah and its relation to science and philosophy, and it could not. Some questions remain. For some of them the answers offered would not satisfy every reader, and I am sure that some of the answers already given will fail that test too. There are even questions for which I have no answer that fully satisfies me.
But the alternative views raise at least as many questions, and to my mind more compelling ones. On one side stand the tradition of the Jewish people, their survival against all odds, the prophecies that have come true, and the grandeur of the Torah itself, some of which this book has tried to show. All of these point to the truth of the Torah, and through it to the existence of God. On the other side, after weighing the alternatives as carefully as I can, I find pictures that are incomplete. They are not strong enough to answer the most fundamental questions, and they are full of gaps. These are not gaps in minor details. They concern the most basic questions of all: where life came from, and how a universe could simply begin, already set to work so precisely. And there are more.
Faced with that choice, it seems to me more sensible not to be troubled by the few verses, out of very many, that raise questions a different reading might well resolve. The alternative is to accept a view that offers no adequate explanation for any of the most basic questions about existence, and that rests on claims for which, in much of the case, there is no evidence at all.
So although I do not have good answers to everything, I am unwilling to let my life depend on how a single word should be interpreted, or on how a difficult passage can be explained. Every other view I know of faces far greater problems. And from all that I have found, the Torah is so extraordinary in so many respects that a few textual difficulties are not enough to overturn my view of it.