One Text, and the Problem of a Late Torah
What we have found shows more than that the Torah is well written, clever and unified. Its unity has a further consequence: it makes it very difficult to argue that the Torah was written late.
Earlier in this part of the book we asked a simple question. If the nation never experienced the events the Torah describes, how did the story of those experiences enter its history? How does one slip a history that never happened into a people’s memory, and when could that have been done? Would the people not have known that what they were being told was a kind of fiction?
The answer usually given is that it entered slowly, piece by piece. No one was ever asked to accept the whole at once. A story here, a law there, a custom given a new explanation, each generation adding a little, until over the centuries the whole came to be believed. It might sound plausible when stated in general terms. In practice it is hard to imagine. Picture the moment at which someone is first told: “Your forefathers stood at a mountain in the wilderness and accepted a law.” “What law?” “Why, the one I am showing you now.” “Then why have I never heard of it before?” Still, one might allow that gradual growth of this kind has a slight possibility, so long as what grew was small and scattered: a few stories, a few customs, loosely gathered over time.
But that is not what the Torah is. It is a single, complete and carefully designed work, of which every part is bound to every other by its structure and by its very words. And it declares itself to be the evidence of the history it records. Moses, it says, wrote “this law” and gave it to the priests, commanding that it be read before all Israel every seven years, and that it be placed beside the ark of the covenant “that it may be there for a witness against you” (Deut 31:9–13, 26). It describes a vast history: a sojourn in a land called Egypt, generations of slavery there, plagues, an exodus, a sea divided, forty years in the wilderness, a revelation at a mountain. If none of this had happened, no one would ever have heard of any of it. A document like that cannot be introduced a little at a time. It either is accepted as a whole, or it is not accepted at all. To slip such a document into a nation’s history, complete with everything that is in it, is impossible.
The theory of separate sources was, in part, what made gradual growth seem reasonable. If the Torah was assembled from many documents, written over many centuries, then each could have entered the nation’s life in its own time and way, and the whole would have accumulated slowly. But if the Torah is one unified work, as everything we have seen suggests, that path is closed. And if, as we have also seen, the later books of the Bible refer to it again and again, then it was not a private composition kept by a few, but a book the whole nation knew. One must then explain how a late and false composition could have become, all at once, the national treasure of a people who had never heard of the events it describes, and who were asked to change their whole way of life because of it.
Some scholars have in fact proposed that the Torah was written as a single work, late in Israel’s history. But that view meets the same difficulty in its sharpest form, and it must also explain how books the critics themselves date earlier could already allude to it. Gradualism does not work well at all. A unified Torah leaves it nowhere to stand.