The Jewish Experience
For most of history, the Jewish people believed the Hebrew Bible to be the word of God. From the earliest records until the past few hundred years, that belief was held by nearly all Jews, and it shaped their lives. The Bible was treated with the utmost seriousness. Its laws were kept in daily life, its words were revered, and it was studied with a dedication few other books have ever received.
That study was never limited to scholars. The Torah was read aloud in public, portion by portion, and ordinary people heard it, learned it, and discussed it. For thousands of years, merchants, craftsmen, and their children studied its text alongside the rabbis. Traditions about how to understand the text go back to times before Christianity. Written commentaries on the Bible, still studied today, date back almost two thousand years. No other community has read this book so closely, for so long, or in such numbers.
This changed in the modern era. As Jews in Europe were emancipated and entered the wider society, they faced challenges to their beliefs that earlier generations had never faced. The intellectual world they joined was the one described above, increasingly shaped by science and by biblical criticism. Many Jews adopted its views and came to reject the Bible as their neighbors had. Many others continue to believe in it firmly, revere it, and keep its laws. But today they are a minority of the Jewish people worldwide. For many Jews, as for most other people, the Torah and the rest of the Hebrew Bible have become irrelevant.
Where Things Stand
The result is the situation described at the start. In much of the Western world, knowledge of the Bible has declined steeply over the past century. For the general public the Hebrew Bible is a collection of old stories contradicted by science. For the educated it is an ancient anthology of uncertain origin. For the religious traditions that grew from it, it is either a preface to a later revelation or a corrupted text. Very few people, anywhere, read it as it presents itself: as a single, purposeful work with something to say to all mankind.
The Approach of This Book
If the Hebrew Bible is to be taken seriously again, many questions must be faced: whether God exists, whether the events it describes happened, whether biblical criticism is right, and how the Bible relates to science. This book deals with all of these to some extent. It does not, however, take them up in the order one might expect.
The usual approach would begin with the existence of God, proceed to the reliability of the text, and only then turn to what the text says. This book reverses that order: relevance first, truth afterward. It begins with an overview of the Hebrew Bible, focusing on the Torah, to show that its message concerns all mankind and not one nation alone. The opening chapters of Genesis are about humanity as a whole, and the story of Israel begins with a promise that through Abraham “shall all the families of the earth be blessed” (Gen 12:3). In the course of that overview it will emerge that the Torah follows an overall plan and structure, consistently and in remarkable detail. A book with such a design cannot easily be the accidental product of editors combining independent documents, so this discussion will, almost without our trying, undermine some of the foundations of biblical criticism.
The book then looks closely at one feature of how the Torah and the other biblical books were written: the way words are linked to one another across passages and across books. These links run straight through the boundaries the critics have drawn between their sources. They also connect the later books of the Bible back to the Torah, as though the later writers had the whole Torah before them and treated it as a blueprint. This too shows that important parts of the critical theory cannot be true. Only after that does the book take up the fundamental questions: the existence of God, the Bible and science, and the Bible and philosophy. It ends by setting the critics’ picture beside the one that has emerged, and asking which better explains the text.
Some readers may object that a book cannot be relevant if it is not true, and that the question of truth should therefore come first. There are two answers. First, relevance is what makes the question of truth worth asking. Few people will examine the evidence for a book they have already dismissed. Second, the evidence that emerges while examining what the Torah says turns out to bear directly on whether it is true. A text built with this kind of consistency and design demands an explanation, and the explanation the critics offer does not fit it. The reader is invited to look at the text first and judge the theories afterward.
On the Use of Jewish Tradition
This book will often rely on traditional Jewish thought and interpretation, for several reasons. Jewish interpreters have worked with the text longer than anyone else. They developed rules of interpretation in ancient times and applied them carefully over many centuries. And, as will be seen, many of the hints and suggestions in their writings lead to a much deeper understanding of the text, an understanding that close examination of the text itself confirms. Most of these interpretations are either ancient or built on methods of interpretation handed down for millennia. For that reason, this book draws on these traditions wherever they help to understand the text, even when modern interpretations differ.