What Happened in Eden
The two chapters before the murder of Abel describe the events in the garden of Eden, and these events also require explanation.
Man is created and placed in a garden. He may eat of every tree but one:
And the LORD God commanded the man, saying: “Of every tree of the garden you may freely eat; but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, you shall not eat of it; for in the day that you eat of it you will surely die.” (Genesis 2:16–17)
The questions come at once. What is “the knowledge of good and evil”? Why should eating from this tree carry so severe a punishment as death? Why create such a tree at all, and why forbid man to eat from it? What was the point?
The Torah makes clear that eating from the tree transformed man. Before the sin, “they were both naked, the man and his wife, and were not ashamed” (2:25). Afterward, “the eyes of them both were opened, and they knew that they were naked; and they sewed fig-leaves together, and made themselves loincloths” (3:7). God then made them better garments than the ones they had made for themselves: “And the LORD God made for Adam and for his wife garments of skins, and clothed them” (3:21). What is going on here?
One thing is clear: man had freedom of will even before the sin. He could choose between right and wrong, and he chose to eat, in violation of God’s command. So eating from the tree did not give man the ability to choose. What, then, did it accomplish? How did it change him?
What the Animals Teach
A clue comes from an unexpected direction. The sages of the Talmud remark that had the Torah never been given, we could have learned proper behavior from the animals: modesty from the cat, not to steal from the ant, fidelity from the dove, and proper conduct from the rooster (Eruvin 100b). They did not mean that all animals behave properly, or that any animal always does. Many animals are anything but modest; the dog, for one. Their point was that a person with a sound moral sense, observing the animal world, could recognize in it the outlines of correct behavior. Notice, too, that two of their four examples correspond directly to commandments of the second tablet: the ant teaches “you shall not steal,” and the dove “you shall not commit adultery.”
Modern research into animal behavior has, in a sense, borne this out. Much of what animals do is governed by instinct, and instinct tends to regulate their conduct in exactly the areas the second tablet addresses.
Consider violence. Animals kill other animals for food, and there is nothing wrong in that; predators even serve a purpose, keeping populations of grazing animals in check, which would otherwise overgraze their environment. Killing within a species is another matter. It does occur, and among some species it is not rare. But in many species instinct restrains it. Rivals contend for dominance or mates in ritualized contests that are rarely fatal: rattlesnakes wrestle instead of biting, and horned and antlered animals spar in ways that seldom kill. Among wolves, a defeated animal may signal submission, and the victor will usually let it go.
Consider possessions. Many animals mark out territories, and the boundaries are generally respected by others of their kind. Consider mating, which in many species follows stable and consistent patterns. Consider communication: animals signal danger to one another, and many signals are reliable precisely because the system depends on their being so.
Instinct is not perfect, and animal behavior is not uniformly admirable. But instinct generally exists, and it generally serves the survival of the species; that is why it is there at all. An instinct that worked against survival would not persist.
Man is different. No creature is as poorly equipped by instinct to govern its own conduct. Man’s capacity for murder, theft, betrayal, and deceit is unique in its extent; nothing in his nature reliably restrains it. This observation is not new. Philosophers have described man as a creature poor in instincts, who must build institutions and laws to do for him what instinct does for other animals. And eight centuries ago Nachmanides, commenting on the tree of knowledge, wrote that before the sin man acted rightly by his nature, as the heavens and the elements follow theirs, and that the fruit of the tree brought him desire, the inclination to choose between good and evil.
This, I suggest, is what happened in Eden. Man lost his instinct.
Before the sin, he had free will, but his nature guided him. Afterward, that inner guidance was gone. The first thing he discovered was that he was naked. Animals need no clothing; whatever modesty they have is instinctive. Man, having lost his instinct, immediately needed an external covering to replace what had been internal. And it is significant that God Himself then provided a better covering than the one man made for himself.