Chapter 7: The Principles Applied: Five Books, Five Stages, section 2 of 6 Overview of chapter 7 Book contents Previous Next

Leviticus: Holiness and Limits

Leviticus corresponds to the third stage. The third level of the tablets, as explained earlier, is the point at which interaction begins: one may use, but not misuse. This implies law, legal rules that set boundaries. That is why law is the central feature not only of the third book of the Torah, but of so many third stages elsewhere, as we have seen.

The idea of holiness is essentially the same. Holiness comes from limitation: from not indulging freely in the physical pleasures of the world. It places restrictions on unrestrained indulgence in this world. Nachmanides, commenting on “You shall be holy” (Leviticus 19:2), explains it in just this way: a person could keep every explicit law of the Torah and still be a glutton and a drunkard, a “scoundrel within the bounds of the Torah”; the command to be holy requires restraint even in what is permitted. Holiness is a major theme of Leviticus. Virtually every section of its law refers to it, or to its opposite, in some way.

Only two events are narrated in Leviticus.

The first is the consecration of the Tabernacle (chapters 8–10): the dedication of a holy place to house the presence of God, who declares Himself holy: “You shall be holy; for I the LORD your God am holy” (19:2). Throughout the book, the refrain “I am the LORD your God,” or simply “I am the LORD,” recurs again and again. The name of God is the subject of the third commandment.

The second event comes near the end of the book. From the Exodus on, most of the sins the Torah recounts are national sins. But two are sins of a single individual, in which the nation as a whole has no part. This is somewhat puzzling. Why should the Torah record the sin of one person? How did it affect the history of the nation?

That question will have to wait. But the sin described in Leviticus 24 is almost exactly what the third commandment forbids: “the son of the Israelite woman blasphemed the Name, and cursed” (24:11).

Numbers: Speech and Testimony

Numbers corresponds to the fourth stage.

The main sin of the book, the sin of the spies, was essentially false testimony, the subject of the ninth commandment, the fourth on the second tablet. The spies’ report was not a simple lie. It began with facts: the land “flows with milk and honey,” its people are strong, its cities fortified (13:27–28). Then came opinion, presented as if it were fact: “We are not able to go up against the people; for they are stronger than we” (13:31). And then came slander: “The land… is a land that eats up its inhabitants” (13:32). The Torah calls it “an evil report of the land” (13:32; 14:36–37). Rashi, commenting on the spies’ opening words, observes that a lie which does not begin with some truth will not stand. Testimony can be false without any single statement being a lie, when facts are mixed with opinion and the whole is designed to mislead.

More generally, most of the sins recorded in Numbers involve improper speech. The people complain (11:1). They weep and clamor for meat (11:4). Miriam and Aaron speak against Moses (12:1). The spies bring their evil report. Korach and his followers rise up against Moses and Aaron with words of rebellion (16:3). The people “spoke against God, and against Moses” (21:5). And the book’s longest narrative concerns Balaam, hired to curse Israel, whose curse turns into blessing. As we saw earlier, speech is a feature of the fourth level: the Sabbath, too, is kept in part through words of testimony.

In Numbers, the condition of the nation also advances beyond where it stood in Exodus. As we saw, when the people complain about water here, they speak with a collective voice, not as individuals.

More important, the book begins with the establishment of an organized camp around the Tabernacle. The nation is formed into a unified “army,” arranged to carry God’s presence into the land of Israel. Yet it is not fully united. Throughout the book, the emphasis is on the tribes. At both the beginning and the end, in the passages that do not describe sins, the tribal leaders are involved and are named again and again: in the census (chapter 1), in the arrangement of the camp (chapter 2), in the offerings at the dedication of the altar, each leader bringing his own offering on his own day (chapter 7), in the order of march (chapter 10), and in the division of the land (34:16–29). The book ends with a law ensuring that every tribe’s inheritance remains within that tribe: “every one of the tribes of the children of Israel shall cleave to its own inheritance” (36:9).

And every person is counted, not once but twice, in two separate censuses, “according to the number of names, every male, head by head” (1:2; see chapter 26).

Each individual still matters on his own. The nation at this stage seems to be an alliance of distinct tribes working together, not yet a perfectly unified people.

Two Sins of Individuals

Numbers also records the second of the two sins of a single individual mentioned earlier: a man is found gathering wood on the Sabbath (15:32–36). This fits the scheme perfectly. The sin against God’s name, the subject of the third commandment, is recorded in the third book; the violation of the Sabbath, the subject of the fourth commandment, is recorded in the fourth. The sages, too, treated the two cases as a pair, since in each the offender was held in custody until Moses received God’s ruling (Sanhedrin 78b).

Why record the sin of a single individual at all? Rashi, following the Midrash, explains that the wood-gatherer’s sin is recorded “to the discredit of Israel”: the people had kept only the first Sabbath, and on the second this man came and desecrated it. The Talmud states elsewhere that if Israel were to keep two Sabbaths properly, they would be redeemed at once (Shabbat 118b). Read together, these sources suggest that one man’s act had consequences for the entire nation, and perhaps for the course of history.

I am not aware of anyone who has noted that the placement of these two events corresponds to the order of the commandments, and I do not suggest that this is the only reason they are recorded. But the correspondence is striking, and it makes the connection between these books and the laws of the tablets clearer still.

Last revised 11 November 2026