Chapter 6: The Law and the Principles of the Tablets, section 5 of 6 Overview of chapter 6 Book contents Previous Next

The Aim of the Law

We have seen that the laws of the second tablet form a progression, from the gravest wrong to the most subtle. We have also seen that the need for law arose from the loss of instinct in Eden.

There is another way to look at that loss. As we saw, without instinct man turned inward, preoccupied with himself. This fits with what we saw about the sin itself: ingratitude is the attitude of one who sees only himself, who takes what he has as his own, owing nothing to anyone.

Instinct, in many species, serves to create a harmonious existence. In some it builds whole communities that live and work together, as among social insects or herds of grazing animals. It establishes boundaries that limit competition and fosters harmony in other ways. The loss of instinct meant the loss of all this. The focus shifted from unity with others to concern with oneself.

The aim of the law, then, is to reverse that shift: to turn man away from self-centeredness and to rebuild his unity with God, with his fellow man, and with all creation. This happens in five distinct steps, outlined by the laws of the tablets, the same step on each tablet.

The first step is the simple recognition that others exist and have a right to exist. On the first tablet, this is the recognition of God’s existence: “I am the LORD your God.” On the second, it is the prohibition of murder, of taking away another’s existence.

The second step goes further: others have rights that extend beyond their own being.

On the first tablet, this means that God is not merely the Creator, but also governs His creation. Idol worshippers did not necessarily deny the existence of a supreme being. Maimonides explains that idolatry began when people reasoned that God had appointed the stars and spheres to govern the world, and so deserved to be honored as His servants; in time the servants came to be worshipped in place of their Master (Laws of Idolatry 1:1). Many idolaters believed that the supreme being was too exalted to involve Himself in mundane matters and had handed the world over to intermediaries. The prohibition of idolatry declares that there are no intermediate gods: the Almighty is in full control of all creation, at all times.

The commandment on the second tablet, “You shall not commit adultery,” expresses the same principle. A person not only has the right to exist; that right extends beyond himself. He can, for example, have a special relationship with a wife that excludes all others from relating to her in the same way. She belongs to her husband alone, not in the sense of property, but in the sense that the bond between them gives him rights that exclude everyone else, until that bond is willingly dissolved. The Talmud describes betrothal in these very terms: the husband makes his wife forbidden to all others “like hekdesh,” like something consecrated to God (Kiddushin 2b). The law of the second tablet echoes the first: just as what is consecrated belongs to God alone, so a wife is set apart for her husband alone.

This principle extends to property as well, though with a difference. The marriage bond is inviolable: no one, not even the husband, can permit another man to live with his wife under any circumstances. Ownership of other things is not inviolable in the same way, as we will see in a moment. But the principle behind ownership is similar to the principle behind the prohibition of adultery: a person’s existence extends beyond himself, and he has the right to control property, territory, and possessions.

This explains why the second section of the mishpatim deals with the rights and duties that arise from owning property. And it explains why the second section of Abraham’s story concerns the acquisition of property: the blessing of wealth, and the walking of the land to take possession of it.

The Third Step: Use, Not Misuse

The first two steps are not relational. They require only the recognition of two realities: that others exist, and that their rights extend to things beyond themselves.

The third step is the first that creates a relationship with others. It allows for interaction on a contractual basis. I may use something that belongs to another, provided I do so within limits: permissible use, not misuse.

On the first tablet, this is the commandment concerning God’s name. God’s name is exalted and may not be used freely; the full name of God was not even pronounced outside the Temple. Yet there are proper uses of it. One may swear a valid oath in God’s name; the Torah itself commands, “by His name you shall swear” (Deuteronomy 6:13). What is forbidden is improper use: a false oath, or an oath taken in vain. “You shall not take the name of the LORD your God in vain.”

The third commandment of the second tablet is “You shall not steal.” The sages understood it to refer specifically to kidnapping, the stealing of a person (Sanhedrin 86a), and kidnapping is punishable by death only if the kidnapper has both used the victim for his own benefit and sold him (see Deuteronomy 24:7). A person may allow someone to employ him, and may allow others to use his property. But this must be done by agreement. There are limits on what I may do with other people or their property. Done properly, the use is permitted; done improperly, by force or without permission, it becomes misuse, and is forbidden.

At first glance “You shall not steal” seems very much like “You shall not commit adultery.” Both forbid taking what belongs to another. But there is a fundamental difference between them. The prohibition of adultery cannot be set aside by permission; the bond it protects cannot be breached in any way. The prohibition of theft concerns things that may normally be used, given permission. It forbids misuse, not use itself.

This explains the unusual collection of laws in the third section of the mishpatim (Exodus 22:13–23).

The first law concerns a person who borrows from another. He becomes responsible for what he has borrowed almost as if he were its owner. In Jewish law a borrower is liable even for unavoidable accidents, a greater responsibility than any other person entrusted with another’s property. This is a clear expression of the principle. One may use an object belonging to another, with permission, but only if one is willing to take full responsibility for it, as if it were one’s own.

The second law requires a man who seduced an unmarried girl to marry her, if her father does not object (22:15–16). One may not use a woman freely. A man may live with a woman only if he is prepared to accept the responsibilities every husband has toward his wife. Again, what is forbidden is misuse.

The laws against witchcraft and against intercourse with an animal (22:17–18) rest on the same principle. Use is permitted; misuse is not. Animals may be used for work and for food, but not for this. In the case of witchcraft, the law teaches that one may use the forces and tools of the world, but within limits; some lie beyond man’s right to use.

Last revised 11 November 2026