Why Placement Matters
One important implication of all this is that the position of something in the Torah is significant. Where a thing is placed tells us something about what it is.
Each book has its own underlying themes and ideas. Even within a book, material at the beginning carries different elements from material at the end. And because the structure of the Torah is fractal, there are several layers to consider when trying to understand why something appears where it does. The book matters; the part of the book matters; the subpart of that part matters; and each may contribute something different.
Take the third book, Leviticus. Everything in it relates to that book’s underlying themes, holiness above all, and that is its most fundamental feature; it explains why a passage is in that book. Then one must consider the part of the book. If a passage is in the first part, its laws will concern the first-level theme: the reality, the existence, of holiness. And if, within that part, it sits in the second subpart, it will carry a second-level theme as well.
This can become complex, and it will not always be easy to see all the nuances of such a system. I do not pretend to understand it all, or to have worked it out in its fine details. But some things stand out and are easy to appreciate.
The idea that placement carries meaning is not new. The sages regularly drew lessons from the juxtaposition of passages, semuchim, asking why one subject is placed next to another (Yevamot 4a), and Rashi raises the question again and again in his commentary. At the same time, the sages taught that “there is no early or late in the Torah” (Pesachim 6b): the Torah does not always present events in the order in which they occurred. If the order is not simply chronological, then something else must govern it. What has been described here suggests what that something is.
A few examples will suffice.
One Day in Three Books
Consider the construction and dedication of the Tabernacle.
The Tabernacle was set up “in the first month in the second year, on the first day of the month” (Exodus 40:17), as described near the very end of Exodus. It was then consecrated, by anointing and by the bringing of offerings, over seven days, and on the eighth day the priests began their service (Leviticus 8–9). According to the sages, during the seven days of consecration the Tabernacle was set up each day and taken down again, and on the eighth day it was set up to stay. That eighth day, they explain, was the first day of Nisan, the same day described at the end of Exodus. Yet the Torah describes it only after a long series of laws, in the book of Leviticus.
Then, in chapter 7 of Numbers, the Torah describes yet another event of that same day, and states explicitly that it took place “on the day that Moses had finished setting up the tabernacle, and had anointed it and sanctified it” (Numbers 7:1). The leaders of the twelve tribes brought offerings for the dedication of the altar, one leader each day, beginning on that day.
The Talmud says that this one day “took ten crowns”: it was the first day of the week of creation, the first day of the leaders’ offerings, the first day of the priesthood, the first day of the Temple service, and more (Shabbat 87b). Yet the Torah divides its account of that day among three separate events, presented not together but in three different books. Why? Whoever arranged the text this way must have had a reason. Why would anyone do such a thing?
A hint of an answer comes at the very end of Numbers 7. The chapter lists the offerings brought by the twelve leaders, one leader each day. The same details are repeated twelve times, in twelve separate sections. Then comes a summation of all the offerings together (7:84–88). And after the summation comes a verse that, on the surface, makes no sense in its place:
And when Moses went into the tent of meeting that He might speak with him, then he heard the Voice speaking to him from above the ark-cover that was upon the ark of the testimony, from between the two cherubim; and He spoke to him. (7:89)
What is this verse doing here? It has nothing to do with the leaders’ offerings, and nothing follows from it in the next chapter. Critical scholars commonly treat it as a stray fragment, displaced from its original context and left where it now stands, the kind of explanation they generally give when a verse does not seem to fit. But perhaps the verse is exactly where it belongs, and its position is the key to the whole puzzle.