Chapter 9: The Themes of the Levels: Law, Sin and Food, section 1 of 5 Overview of chapter 9 Book contents Previous Next

A Note to the Reader

What is being argued in this book is that the Torah’s material is organized according to a fairly consistent pattern, and that this one basic pattern repeats itself at different structural levels: the Torah as a whole, each of its books, the parts of each book, and smaller units still. The pattern is not mechanical. There are exceptions, and there are complexities, some of which I understand and some of which I do not. But the pattern is there, and it recurs.

One consequence follows naturally. If the same pattern governs units of every size, then passages that stand in the same relative position within their units should share similar ideas and themes. The fourth section of a book should resemble, in some way, the fourth book of the Torah. The second part of a section should echo the second part of another. This is indeed what we find. And once one begins to look for patterns in the Torah, one finds other kinds of patterns as well: repeated words, mirrored sequences and themes that answer one another across great distances.

All of this, however, is difficult to demonstrate without first establishing the units themselves. Before one can say that two passages occupy the same position, one must know where each unit begins and ends, which pieces of text belong to which structural level, and which units are nested inside which. To do this comprehensively, for the entire Torah, would require far more than most readers who are not scholars would be willing to read.

I will provide a map of the overall structure, at the end of the book. But even a map will not be enough, for three reasons:

  • The structure is complex.
  • Unless one knows the Torah extremely well, a list of chapter and verse references, even with short descriptions of their contents, will mean little.
  • Without explanation, parts of the map may not be understandable, and some divisions may be disputed.

I could also explain how I go about determining where the boundaries lie. But a discussion of method in the abstract is not the most interesting reading, and it would not necessarily be useful.

So I must ask the reader for a measure of trust. At times I will say that a certain section belongs to the fourth level, or to some other level, without showing why. At times I will say, without further explanation, that one subunit ends here and the next begins there. In many cases the divisions are self-evident, and any attentive reader will see them at once. In many others the dividing lines are not obvious at first. They became clear to me only after long and careful work.

After many years of that work, I believe I understand the overall structure of the entire text, and I am confident that this understanding will stand the test of time. Where an explanation is needed to follow the argument, or where a division is likely to surprise, I will give one. Elsewhere I will simply state the division and move on. I ask the reader to judge the structure by its fruits: by whether the patterns it reveals, taken together, are too many and too consistent to be accidental.

Last revised 15 November 2026