Chapter 9: The Themes of the Levels: Law, Sin and Food, section 5 of 5 Overview of chapter 9 Book contents Previous Next

Food and the Fourth Level

Certain themes recur at particular structural levels. One of the most persistent is food and eating. Why this theme should belong to the fourth level is not entirely clear to me, but the pattern is hard to miss.

We noted one possible clue earlier. The chuppah, the fourth step in the marriage process, creates the husband’s obligation to provide for his wife, and above all to feed her (Exod 21:10). This may be a stretch, but as we shall see it may also contain some truth. Another possible clue is that the first sin of all was a sin of eating. Neither, however, fully explains why food should be tied to the concepts of the fourth level.

In narrative. The sin in Eden forms the fourth subunit of the first part of Genesis, and it contains one of the densest clusters of the verb “to eat” (achal) in the entire Torah. From God’s command in 2:16 to the expulsion in 3:22, the verb occurs twenty-one times in thirty-two verses. No other narrative passage in the Torah comes close. The test given to man was a test of restraint in eating, and it was the test he failed. Food fills the whole setting: a garden “every tree that is pleasant to the sight, and good for food” (2:9), and a sentence that ends with bread eaten “in the sweat of your face” (3:19).

The fourth section of Abraham’s life opens with Abraham feeding three strangers (18:1-8). The scene is repeated when Lot does the same in Sodom: “and he made them a feast… and they ate” (19:3).

Jacob’s history forms the fourth part of Genesis, and its pivotal act, the taking of the blessing, revolves around food. Isaac asks for “savoury food, such as I love” (27:4), and the deception itself is carried out with food. Rebekah prepares the dish, and Jacob serves it in his brother’s place. Earlier still, Jacob acquired the birthright with “bread and lentil stew” (25:34).

In the first part of Exodus, the sins of the fourth subunit concern food and drink: the bitter water at Marah, the hunger in the wilderness of Sin, the thirst at Massah and Meribah (15:22-17:7). And here God first gives the manna (ch. 16). If Israel stands to God as a wife to her husband, this is God fulfilling a husband’s obligation to feed his wife. Seen this way, the complaints become more understandable: a wife who fears she will not be provided for. The prophet uses exactly this image. The faithless wife says, “I will go after my lovers, who give me my bread and my water… For she did not know that it was I who gave her the grain, and the wine, and the oil” (Hos 2:7, 10).

Several of the major sins in Numbers, the fourth book, also involve food and drink: the craving for meat (“If only we were given meat to eat! We remember the fish, which we used to eat in Egypt for nothing,” Num 11:4-5), the waters of Meribah, and the complaint that ended in the plague of serpents, “there is no bread, and there is no water; and our soul loathes this light bread” (21:5).

Food in the Laws

The theme is not limited to narrative. It appears in fourth-level legal sections as well.

  • The mishpatim. Several laws in their fourth section concern food: torn flesh is not to be eaten (Exod 22:30); in the seventh year the poor and the beasts of the field eat the produce (23:11); unleavened bread is eaten for seven days (23:15); the festival offering may not remain until morning (23:18); a kid may not be seethed in its mother’s milk (23:19).

  • Leviticus 6:1-7:21 (or 7:27). The first seven chapters of Leviticus form a single unit, bound together by a summary at the end (7:37-38). Its fourth subunit, as I understand it, begins at 6:1. This subunit too is about the eating of holy food: by the altar, which consumes some offerings entirely; by the priests; and by those who bring the offerings. The contrast with what precedes it is stark. In the first five chapters of Leviticus, 111 verses, the verb “to eat” appears once. From 6:1 to the end of the subunit it appears more than twenty times.

  • Leviticus 10:12-11:47. In the first part of Leviticus as a whole, the fourth subunit comes after the death of Nadav and Avihu. The question it raises is what should be done with the offerings, and in particular whether they should have been eaten (10:12-20). It is followed immediately by the laws of permitted and forbidden animals (ch. 11). Whether these laws belong to the fourth subunit or the fifth is debatable. They do speak of impurity, and the five vayedaber units that follow (chs. 12-15) are all about impurity. But those five deal with impurity that arises from people, and in my view they form a closed set of five levels of their own. I therefore believe that the dietary laws belong with what precedes them, in the fourth subunit, though I recognize that this can be disputed.

  • Leviticus 22. The fourth part of Leviticus opens with a section on the eating of holy food: who among the priests and their households may eat it, and when (22:1-16).

The golden calf also mentions eating and drinking: “and the people sat down to eat and to drink, and rose up to make merry” (Exod 32:6). This may be incidental, since such phrases occur elsewhere as well.

None of this is meant to imply that food cannot appear elsewhere in the Torah. It does. But there seems to be a consistent emphasis on food in fourth-level passages, both narrative and legal, and it is too regular to be easily dismissed.

Last revised 11 November 2026