The Five Parts of Numbers
As noted earlier, not every area of the text is built on the five principles, and not every unit large enough to be divided into five subunits actually divides that way. One of the main exceptions is the second part of Numbers. To see why, we must first look at the book as a whole.
That Numbers consists of five parts is, to my mind, clear.
The first part (chs. 1-10) describes how the nation was organized: the census, the arrangement of the camp around the Tabernacle, the role of the Levites, and the preparations for departure. All of this led to the first journey from Sinai, which was meant to bring the nation straight to Canaan to begin its conquest. As we have said several times, this organization was a step upward in the nation’s development. Because it took place at the fourth level, it was meant ultimately to bring the nation to the end of days, the full rectification of the sin in Eden.
The second part records how things fell apart almost at once. In the early part of their stay in the wilderness, the people committed a series of sins. The nation fell from the high status described at the beginning of the book, and its progress toward its final goal was halted.
The third part is the law of the red heifer (ch. 19), and it fits its place well. The history recorded before it ends with the rebellion of Korach, which seems to have occurred shortly after the sin of the spies, since it refers to that sin’s aftermath (16:13-14). The history after it resumes early in the fortieth year. Between the two lie the “silent” years, about which the Torah tells us only one thing: the entire generation that left Egypt died in the wilderness (14:29-35). The red heifer purifies from the impurity of death. It was needed precisely during those intervening years, when death was everywhere. Death, too, seems to be a theme of the fourth level, probably because it entered the world through Adam’s sin in Eden, the quintessential fourth-level event.
The fourth part (chs. 20-25) contains another series of episodes. As we shall see, these rectify, at least in part, the sins of the second part.
The fifth part opens with the census of chapter 26 and is largely devoted to preparing the nation for entering and conquering Canaan.
Three National Sins
The second part of Numbers records three major national sins. (I leave aside for now Miriam’s speech against Moses and the man who gathered wood on the Sabbath, which are individual rather than national.) Each of the three is directed against a different object.
- The craving for food (ch. 11) was an affront to Moses. We can see this from his reaction. He asks to be relieved of the burden: “I am not able to bear all this people myself alone, because it is too heavy for me” (11:14). In response, God appoints seventy elders to share his leadership. The sages also teach that the manna was given in Moses’ merit (Ta’anit 9a), so a complaint about the manna was in effect a complaint against him.
- The sin of the spies (chs. 13-14) was directed against God, against His ability to bring Israel into the land. “We are not able to go up against the people; for they are stronger than we” (13:31). The sages read the last word as “stronger than He” (Sotah 35a). God’s own response names the sin: “How long will they not believe in Me?” (14:11).
- The rebellion of Korach (chs. 16-17) was directed against Aaron and his priesthood. “And as for Aaron, what is he that you murmur against him?” (16:11). The rebellion ends with the blossoming of Aaron’s rod, which confirms his priesthood (17:16-26).
Three Rectifications
In the fourth part, which describes the fortieth year, each of these sins is rectified to some degree.
The first episode of chapter 20 is again a demand for water, and it records the sin of Moses and Aaron that cost them their entry into the land (20:2-13). But then comes the episode of the serpents. The people complain once more about the food, “our soul loathes this light bread” (21:5). This time, though, they admit their sin and turn to Moses for help: “We have sinned, because we have spoken against the LORD, and against you; pray to the LORD” (21:7). Shortly afterward comes the song at the well: “Spring up, O well, sing to it; the well, which the princes dug, which the nobles of the people dug out” (21:17-18). The song credits the nation’s leaders with giving the people water. Rashi identifies these “princes” as Moses and Aaron. This is a measure of rectification for the affront to Moses.
The deaths of Miriam (20:1) and Aaron (20:22-29) both fall in this same part. They may be connected to the fact that the two of them spoke improperly against Moses immediately after Kivrot ha-Ta’avah (12:1). Their sin was also an affront to him.
Then come the victories. The king of Arad attacks and is defeated (21:1-3), just before the serpents. After the song of the well, Sihon and Og are conquered (21:21-35). Then, after only a closed break, comes the story of Balaam (22:2-24:25). Together these events prove what the spies had denied: God cares for His people, and He can defeat their enemies whenever He chooses. Balaam, hired to curse, is forced to declare, “The LORD his God is with him” (23:21).
There is a striking detail in the first of these victories. After the sin of the spies, the people who tried to invade on their own were driven back “as far as Hormah” (14:45). Now Israel defeats the Canaanites at Arad, “and the name of the place was called Hormah” (21:3). The defeat is reversed at the very place it occurred. This is a partial rectification of the sin of the spies.
After Balaam comes Shittim, where Pinchas receives “the covenant of an everlasting priesthood” (25:13). This reverses what happened with Korach. Korach claimed the priesthood and was rejected. Pinchas proves himself worthy of it and receives it. The parallel goes further. In the aftermath of Korach’s rebellion, Aaron stood “between the dead and the living; and the plague was stopped” (17:13). At Shittim, Pinchas acts, and again “the plague was stopped” (25:8). The sages teach that Pinchas had not previously been made a priest (Zevachim 101b). Here that omission is made good. In this sense, Shittim rectifies the sin of Korach.
| Sin (part 2) | Against | Rectification (part 4) |
|---|---|---|
| Craving for food (ch. 11) | Moses | Serpents: “we have sinned… against you; pray” (21:7); song of the well (21:17-18) |
| Spies (chs. 13-14) | God | Hormah reversed (21:3); Sihon and Og (21:21-35); Balaam (chs. 22-24) |
| Korach (chs. 16-17) | Aaron | Pinchas receives an everlasting priesthood (25:10-15) |
We should be careful not to push the five principles too far. They describe progress, and they are not necessarily a guide to sin. Sin arrests progress and may follow a pattern of its own. The sins of the earliest generations did follow the five principles, in negative form, as violations of the second tablet. But the sins of the wilderness follow a different logic: three sins and three rectifications, arranged according to whom each sin offended.