Chapter 9: The Themes of the Levels: Law, Sin and Food, section 3 of 5 Overview of chapter 9 Book contents Previous Next

Law as the Driving Force

In each of the first four books, the first part has a more complex structure than any other part of that book. The first part of Leviticus, chapters 1 to 15, consists of about sixteen units of text, either divine speeches (vayedaber units) or units of narrative. By contrast, the second and fifth parts each consist of a single vayedaber unit, and the third and fourth parts consist of five each. The other three books show the same imbalance: the first part is always the most intricate.

These four first parts share a further feature, and it is one they share with the Torah as a whole.

Consider the Torah’s large structure. The history told in Numbers is really a continuation of the history told in Exodus. In Exodus the nation is created; in Numbers it is organized. Apart from the few chapters of Leviticus that describe the consecration of the Tabernacle, one could skip the rest of that book and read straight from Exodus through the consecration into Numbers without missing anything in the story. Leviticus, the book of law, stands between what would otherwise be one continuous history.

The same thing happens in the first part of each of the first four books. In each, a historical narrative is interrupted by law, or in Genesis by material of a legal character, and then resumes.

Numbers shows this most simply. The second subunit of its first part describes the transfer of the firstborn’s sacred role to the Levites (chs. 3-4). But the matter is not finished there. Chapter 8 completes it with the ceremony that consecrated the Levites for their new status (8:5-26). Between the two lie laws unrelated to the Levites:
- the removal of the impure from the camp;
- restitution for theft;
- the wife suspected of adultery;
- the Nazirite;
- the priestly blessing.

After these comes the inauguration of the altar (ch. 7). Law has been placed in the middle of a single narrative and has broken it in two.

Exodus does the same. The second subunit of its first part ends with the exodus itself: “It was a night of watching to the LORD for bringing them out from the land of Egypt” (12:42). An open break follows. Then comes law: “This is the ordinance of the passover (zot chukat ha-pesach)” (12:43-50). Verse 51 restates that the LORD brought Israel out of Egypt “that very day,” and an open break closes the unit. The word chukah here is itself a mark of law at the third level, as we have seen. A second set of laws follows, on the firstborn and on unleavened bread (13:1-16). These are joined to the following narrative by closed breaks only. The story resumes at 13:17: “Now when Pharaoh had let the people go…” Again, law interrupts history.

Leviticus follows suit. The second subunit of its first part is the consecration of the Tabernacle and its priests, beginning in chapter 8. After the death of Nadav and Avihu, an open break follows 10:7. Then God speaks to Aaron alone, the only vayedaber in the Torah addressed to him by himself (10:8-11):

“Drink no wine or strong drink, you or your sons with you, when you go into the tent of meeting… and that you may distinguish between the holy and the common… and that you may teach the children of Israel all the statutes which the LORD has spoken to them by the hand of Moses.”

Another open break follows, and at 10:12 the narrative about the same day’s events resumes.

The law in these verses does not mention Nadav and Avihu. The sages connected it to their death, but the text does not say so (Lev Rabbah 12:1). And if the intention had been to make the passage one continuous piece, closed breaks would have sufficed. Placing the law between open breaks marks it as a separate unit, one that interrupts the flow of narrative and produces the same structure we found in Exodus and Numbers.

Genesis has the same pattern at its very beginning. The first five days of creation are a prelude to the creation of man on the sixth. Then the account is interrupted by another day, the Sabbath (2:1-3), set off by open breaks on both sides. The Sabbath is not yet commanded as law, but it is the most law-like passage in the account: a day blessed, sanctified and set apart. After it, the story of the creation of man resumes, now told in far greater detail (2:4-25).

In every case, what follows the interruption stands on a higher level than what came before it.

  • In Numbers, the order is selection, then law, then consecration: the Levites are first chosen, and after the interposed law they are purified and dedicated.
  • In Exodus, the order is the exodus, then law, then the pillar of cloud and fire and the splitting of the sea. The first events show God’s care for the nation; those after the law show a closer and greater care: He goes before them day and night and divides the sea for them.
  • In Leviticus the progression is less clear, but it may be present as well.
  • In Genesis it is clear. The first account of man’s creation is simple: man is created in God’s image and given dominion. The second is much richer. It describes a garden planted for man, four great rivers, a first command, the naming of the animals and the creation of woman. The first account describes man’s existence; the second describes his place, his task and his relationships. The status it depicts is higher.

This is also the pattern of the Torah as a whole: a first history in Exodus, the law of Leviticus, and a more developed history in Numbers. The nation itself is more developed in Numbers: structured and organized, encamped by tribes around the Tabernacle, ready to carry God’s presence to the promised land. Even the words the Torah uses for it change. An am, a people, is a collection of individuals who share a common ancestry or culture. An edah, a congregation, is a nation organized as a body. Exodus calls Israel an am far more often than an edah; in Numbers, as we noted earlier, edah is far more frequent than anywhere else in the Torah.

The implication is that law is the driving force of the development the Torah describes. Progress takes place as law after law is given, accepted and followed. That is why law is so integral to the Torah and why it is interwoven with the narrative. The narrative records development; the law makes it possible. Its placement at the major turning points of the story is not an arbitrary feature of the text. It reflects the Torah’s view of what moves history forward.

The Two Accounts of Creation

This has a direct bearing on one of the foundational arguments of biblical criticism. Since the nineteenth century, critics have treated the opening chapters of Genesis as two separate creation stories from two different sources:
- a “Priestly” account (1:1-2:4a), which uses the name Elohim;
- an older account (2:4b-25), which uses the name YHWH Elohim.

The two differ in style and in detail. In the first, plants and animals are created before man; in the second, man appears first and the garden and the animals follow. On this view, an editor placed two incompatible traditions side by side.

The pattern traced here suggests a different explanation. The doubling is not unique to Genesis. Exodus, Leviticus and Numbers also tell a story, interrupt it with law, and resume it on a higher level. If a doubled account separated by legal material were a sign of combined sources, we would have to suppose that the same accident of editing happened in exactly the same place, the first part, of four separate books.

Moreover, the critics themselves generally assign the whole opening of Numbers (1:1-10:10) to a single source, the Priestly writer. There the pattern cannot be the seam between two documents. And if the pattern appears where critics see one source, it cannot be evidence of two sources where they see two.

The physical text points the same way. The traditional open breaks around the Sabbath fall after 1:31 and after 2:3, exactly where the structure described here places them. The critics’ dividing line falls in the middle of a verse (2:4), where the text has no break at all.

Seen this way, the second account is not a rival version of the first. It is the next stage. The first account establishes that man exists. The Sabbath intervenes. The second account then places man in a relationship with God, with the world and with woman, and gives him his first command. The differences between the two accounts, which critics take as signs of contradiction, are precisely what we should expect if the second describes a higher level, with a different emphasis, than the first.

Last revised 11 November 2026