Law, the Critics and Christian Readers
For the critical tradition more broadly. Classical criticism, as formulated by Julius Wellhausen in the nineteenth century, placed the law late. On his account, the legal material, above all the priestly law of Leviticus, came after the prophets and represented a decline from an earlier, freer religion. The structure traced here points the other way. Law is not a late layer added to the narrative; it is woven into the narrative at its turning points, and it is what drives the development the narrative describes. It is worth recording that Wellhausen’s ranking of law below prophecy did not arise in a vacuum. Solomon Schechter, writing in 1903, already charged that some of this scholarship expressed a hostility to Judaism. Readers today need not accept that charge in order to see that the low estimate of law was a judgment, not a finding.
Scholarship has also moved on. Many scholars today no longer hold the classical four-document theory in its original form, and debate continues over how the Torah was formed. A growing number of “literary” readers, both Jewish and non-Jewish, now study the final form of the text and find deliberate artistry in it. This book’s argument is addressed to every version of the claim that the Torah’s design is secondary to its sources.
For Christian readers. Christianity shares with Judaism the conviction that the story of Genesis 3 shapes all that follows: “by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin” (Rom 5:12). Both traditions read history as a movement from the loss of Eden toward its restoration. The difference lies in what accomplishes that restoration.
In much of Christian thought, especially in the tradition shaped by Paul’s letters, the law could not by itself bring life. It served as a guardian or “schoolmaster” until the coming of Christ (Gal 3:21-24), and its role was therefore preparatory and temporary. Christian traditions differ on this. Some stress the law’s continuing moral force, and Jesus himself is reported as saying he came “not to destroy, but to fulfil” (Matt 5:17).
The structure traced in this book presents the Torah’s own answer to that question, as its arrangement expresses it. Law is placed at the turning points of the narrative; progress follows its acceptance, and decline follows its violation. The Oral Law’s own arrangement presents the commandments as the means by which the consequences of Eden are undone. Read on its own terms, the Torah does not present law as a temporary stage on the way to something else. It presents law as the instrument of rectification itself. Christian readers will weigh this against their own tradition’s reading. But they too have reason to take the Torah’s design seriously: the more deliberate the design, the more the Torah’s own view of law deserves to be heard in its own voice.