Conclusion: One Text
We began this part of the book with a question. If the Torah was assembled from separate documents, written by different authors in different centuries and later joined by an editor, its words should show it. A writer echoes his own words; he cannot echo words in a document he never saw. The connections we have been tracing should therefore stay within each source and stop at its borders.
They do not stop there. Again and again we found them crossing the borders the critics have drawn, and most often the borders around P, the ones critics consider the most certain of all:
- The list of Edom’s kings and chiefs in Genesis 36 reaches forward into the story of Joseph, the story of Judah and Tamar, the baker’s dream in Egypt, and the Song of the Sea.
- The two verses on Esau’s wives at the end of chapter 26 reach back to Isaac’s wells and forward to his failing eyes and the smell of Esau’s garments.
- Keturah’s sons answer Isaac in the field, Esau faint from the hunt, and the wells filled with earth, and they reach across to the genealogy of Ishmael.
- Nahor’s sons look back to the wood of the Akedah and forward to the field, the trees and the cave of Machpelah. Rebekah, the daughter for whose sake the genealogy was written, is followed at once by the greatest cluster of “grave” and “bury” anywhere in the Bible, and the man who sold the grave is named “dust.”
- The table of nations carries out Noah’s blessing and curse, and its seventy nations match the seventy souls of Israel.
- The cloud of the covenant gives way to the first mention of Canaan.
- The mighty men of the Flood’s prelude are answered by waters that prevail over them, in verses the critics give to the other author.
- The first account of creation ends with the very words, “all,” “eat” and “herb,” that the second account takes up and makes its themes. The verse said to divide them is built almost entirely from the words of the seventh day.
In every case we examined, the passage assigned to P was woven into the passages around it, and woven in by its words. These were not common words of the kind any writer might happen to share. Most were rare words, names that no story required, and words found only in that one place and its partner. None of these P passages simply sits beside its neighbors. Each has a reason for standing where it does: it answers what came before, prepares what comes after, or both. If an editor took these passages from another document and set them in place, he did far more than set them in place. He must have chosen and shaped their words to fit the surrounding text, and someone who does that is not an editor but an author.
Not every passage has been examined, and not every question has been answered. Some of the connections we have seen are stronger than others, and a careful reader may doubt one or another of them. But the argument does not rest on any single case. It rests on the pattern, repeated across passage after passage: wherever we looked, the connections ran across the borders as freely as within them. Nowhere did the words show a seam.
This matters especially because of where we looked. The theory of sources was first worked out in Genesis, and Genesis remains its foundation. In Genesis, the critics say, the documents can be told apart most clearly. There, they argue, the names of God divide them, the vocabulary of each was identified, and the profiles later used to sort the rest of the Torah were drawn up. The passages examined here are among the most important in that foundation: the first account of creation, the Flood, the table of nations, the genealogies of the patriarchs, and the list of Edom. If P cannot be separated from its neighbors in these passages, the method that separated it has failed where it was supposed to be strongest. The same kind of analysis can be applied to the remaining passages of Genesis, and to the rest of the Torah. If P does not exist as a separate document in Genesis, the case for it elsewhere loses the ground it was built on.
Two subjects remain. The first is the names of God, on which the theory was originally based. Today even many critics no longer regard them as decisive, and they raise serious difficulties of their own for the theory’s foundations. We will turn to them later.
The second follows directly from what we have seen. So far, almost all the connections have joined words within a few verses or a few chapters of each other. Yet some have reached much farther: from the kings of Edom to the Song of the Sea, and from the brothers’ grief over Dinah to Joseph’s words of comfort eleven chapters later.
The next chapters will show that this is not unusual. Word connections of the same kind link passages separated by entire books.
What emerges from the evidence of the words is a text of remarkable unity. Its wording is precise and its connections are deliberate, and each part stands where it does for a reason. A text like this was not pieced together by an editor from scraps of older documents. It was written as a whole.