The Ritual as a Picture
Maimonides explains the ritual in practical terms (Guide for the Perplexed III:40), and Abarbanel takes the same view. In an age without newspapers, a ceremony like this one draws attention. The elders of the town gather, judges come out to measure distances, and a heifer is taken down to a wild valley and killed there. People hear of it, talk about it, and rack their brains to think who could have done such a thing: a stranger passing through, someone known to be violent, someone with a grudge. The ritual turns a quiet crime into a public question, and a public question is how a killer is found.
That explanation accounts for the ceremony as a whole. It does not obviously account for its details. Why a young animal? Why one that has never worked? Why a valley that has never been plowed or sown? If the law is read against the story of Joseph, the details take on a meaning of their own. The ritual becomes a picture of what was lost when a young man was killed. It also pictures what Jacob believed he had lost when he was shown his son’s coat.
- The animal. It is a young bovine, a heifer “of the herd.” Joseph is the ox of the tribes. Moses calls him “his firstborn ox” (Deut 33:17), and tradition reads Jacob’s rebuke of Simeon and Levi, “in their self-will they hamstrung oxen” (Gen 49:6), as referring to him. At the time of the sale, he was still young: “Joseph, being seventeen years old… being still a lad” (Gen 37:2). The animal of the ritual is not a grown ox but a young one.
- Never worked. It “has not been worked with, and… has not drawn in the yoke.” The slain man of the law, like Joseph, is pictured as one whose working life had not yet begun. He had not yet taken up the yoke of a man’s labor, and now he never will. The word for “worked,” ubad, is from E-B-D, the root of eved, “slave.” Joseph never took up a free man’s work. He was sold instead, and became “the Hebrew slave (eved)” (Gen 39:17); as the psalm puts it, “Joseph was sold for a slave” (Ps 105:17).
- Barren. A young heifer has not yet borne young. Joseph, when he was sold, had no wife and no children. His sons were born only years later in Egypt (Gen 41:50). The man whose life is cut off leaves no one after him.
- The valley. The heifer is taken to “a rough valley, which may neither be plowed nor sown” (Deut 21:4). Here the picture moves from the animal to the place. The ground has never been worked, and nothing will be sown in it. The word for “sown” is from zera, “seed,” which throughout the Torah also means offspring. A field that is never sown is land that will never yield. It is a picture of a life that will produce neither work nor children.
- Brought down. The elders “bring down” the heifer to the valley. Joseph was “brought down” to Egypt (Gen 39:1), and Jacob, mourning, said: “I will go down to the grave to my son mourning” (Gen 37:35).
- The neck broken. The animal’s life ends suddenly and violently, in a desolate place, far from anyone. That is how a man found slain in the field died. It is also how Jacob believed his son had died: “an evil beast has devoured him” (37:33). Beasts of prey often kill in just this way, by seizing the neck.
Each element is, on its own, a reasonable part of a ritual meant to impress itself on the public. Taken together, they portray a life cut off before it had begun, without work and without children. That is what happened to the slain man of the law, and it is what Jacob believed had happened to Joseph.