After the Calf
In Exodus, the sin of the calf is followed by the building of the Tabernacle. That is not an event like the others, and the later chapters of Judges do not reflect it directly. Those chapters tell of two more judges, Jephthah and Samson, and then of two episodes of a different kind: the shrine of Micah (Judg 17–18), and the outrage at Gibeah, the story of the concubine (pilegesh be-Giv’ah, Judg 19–21).
Micah’s shrine. The story of Micah fits the theme of the whole book. It is more idol worship, but now organized, with a “house of God,” an ephod, household images and a hired priest. It ends with the tribe of Dan carrying the images off and setting them up in their new city, where they stood “all the time that the house of God was in Shiloh” (18:31). In a sense it is the opposite of what happened in Exodus. There, after the calf, the people gave their gifts to build a sanctuary for God. Here, Micah’s mother consecrates her silver “to the LORD,” and what she has made from it is “a carved image and a molten image (pesel u-massechah)” (17:3). The calf, too, was “a molten calf (egel massechah)” (Exod 32:4).
The other three episodes do not seem to relate directly to anything in Exodus. They do link to other parts of the Torah. The clearest and strongest of these links is the story of Gibeah.
Gibeah and Sodom
The story of the concubine at Gibeah echoes the story of Sodom, both in its details and in its overall flow. Many have noticed this, Nachmanides (Ramban) among them, in his commentary on the story of Sodom. Two verses in particular are almost identical. When the men of Sodom surround Lot’s house, they demand his guests:
“And they called to Lot, and said to him: ‘Where are the men who came in to you this night? bring them out to us, that we may know them.’” (Gen 19:5)
When the men of Gibeah surround the old man’s house, they demand his guest:
”…and they spoke to the master of the house, the old man, saying: ‘Bring out the man who came into your house, that we may know him.’” (Judg 19:22)
Lot answers by offering his daughters:
“Behold now, I have two daughters who have not known man; let me, please, bring them out to you, and do to them as is good in your eyes; only to these men do nothing; since they have come under the shadow of my roof.” (Gen 19:8)
The old man answers in almost the same words:
“Behold, here is my daughter a virgin, and his concubine; I will bring them out now, and humble them, and do with them what seems good to you; but to this man do not do so wanton a thing.” (Judg 19:24)
Nachmanides examines the differences between the two accounts and explains them. He shows that the sin of Gibeah, terrible as it was, was less severe than the sin of Sodom.
The overall flow of the two stories is also almost identical.
A single story. In the Torah scroll, the story of Sodom is presented as one uninterrupted unit. It begins at Gen 18:1, after an open break in the text. From there it runs without any break to the end of chapter 19, which closes with a closed break. After that comes an entirely new matter, the story of Abraham and Abimelech. The visit of the angels to Abraham, his plea for the cities, the destruction of Sodom and the story of Lot’s daughters are all one continuous passage.
It begins with hospitality. The story of Sodom opens with Abraham’s hospitality to his three visitors (18:1–8). Then, more briefly, comes Lot’s hospitality to two of them (19:1–3). The story of Gibeah also begins with hospitality, and in two stages: first the father-in-law in Bethlehem, who keeps the Levite for days of eating and drinking, and then the old man of Gibeah, who takes the travelers in for the night. The language matches. Abraham offers “a morsel of bread, and sustain your heart (ve-sa’adu libchem)” (Gen 18:5). The father-in-law says “Sustain your heart (se’ad libcha) with a morsel of bread” (Judg 19:5). Lot’s guests intend to spend the night “in the broad place (ba-rechov)” (Gen 19:2). In Gibeah the travelers sit down “in the broad place of the city” (Judg 19:15), and the old man tells them, “only do not lodge in the broad place” (19:20). In the Bible, a night’s lodging in “the broad place” is mentioned only in these two stories.
Sinful conduct. In both cities the men surround the house at night and demand the guests. The two near-identical verses quoted above stand at the center of each story.
Destruction, and by fire. Sodom is destroyed by “brimstone and fire from the LORD out of heaven” (Gen 19:24). Gibeah and the cities of Benjamin are destroyed in war, and the victors burn them: “also all the cities which they found they set on fire” (Judg 20:48). The scene of the burning echoes the Torah’s account. Lot’s wife “looked back from behind him (me-acharav)” (Gen 19:26). The next morning Abraham “looked out toward Sodom … and saw, and, lo, the smoke of the land went up (ve-hineh alah) like the smoke of a furnace” (19:28). At Gibeah, “the Benjamites looked behind them (acharav), and, behold, the whole of the city went up (ve-hineh alah) in smoke to heaven” (Judg 20:40).
A problem of marriage. In each story the destruction leaves behind a problem of marriage, and it is resolved in an irregular way. Lot’s daughters, believing no man is left on earth, conceive by their father (Gen 19:31–38). At the end of Judges, the surviving six hundred men of Benjamin have no wives, since the other tribes have sworn not to give them their daughters. They are allowed first to take the virgins of Jabesh-Gilead, and then to seize wives from among the girls dancing at Shiloh (Judg 21).
Kingship. Both stories lead to kingship. Lot’s daughters bear Moab and Ammon. From Moab comes Ruth, the ancestress of King David. From Ammon comes Naamah, the wife of Solomon and mother of the next king, Rehoboam (1 Kgs 14:21). The Talmud makes this explicit, calling Ruth the Moabite and Naamah the Ammonite the “two good doves” for whose sake those nations were spared (Bava Kamma 38b). The first king of Israel, Saul, comes from the tribe of Benjamin, the tribe of the men who seized their wives. His home is Gibeah itself (1 Sam 10:26). His first act as king is to rescue Jabesh-Gilead (1 Sam 11), the city from which Benjamin had taken its first wives. The text of Judges even hints at what is to come, through the refrain that runs through its last chapters: “In those days there was no king in Israel” (17:6; 18:1; 19:1; 21:25).
A Test by Computer
Many years ago I tested this connection by computer. I made a list of the words in the story of Sodom that occur fifty times or fewer in the entire Bible, so that common words would not swamp the result. A program then searched the Bible for the places where those words cluster. The largest cluster outside the story of Sodom itself was in the story of Gibeah. In other words, the story of the concubine contains more of the rarer words of the Sodom story than any other passage of comparable size in the rest of the Bible.
Whatever one makes of the individual parallels, the conclusion is clear. The story of Gibeah is related to the story of Sodom, and linked to it deliberately.