The Brothers Repeat the Curse
The story does not end there, and here matters become worse. Years later, the brothers come down to Egypt to buy grain, without Benjamin. Joseph does not reveal who he is. He has reason to suspect that they may have done to Rachel’s other son what they did to him, and he will not make himself known until he is sure. So he demands that they bring Benjamin to him. When they do, he wants to see what they will do if Benjamin is put in danger. He tells his steward to hide his silver cup in Benjamin’s sack. Then he sends them away, and sends the steward after them to accuse them of theft.
The brothers, certain of their innocence, make the very mistake their father had made before them:
“With whomever of your servants it is found, let him die, and we also will be my lord’s slaves.” (Gen 44:9)
Like their father, they condemn to death not the thief but “with whomever it is found.” Jacob said “with whomever you find” (im asher timtza). His sons said “with whomever it is found” (asher yimatze itto). The steward softens the sentence: “he with whom it is found shall be my slave” (44:10). But the words have been spoken. Once again they fall, without anyone intending it, on a child of Rachel. The cup is found in Benjamin’s sack.
Gibeah. I believe that this second curse, spoken by the brothers, led to the near destruction of the tribe of Benjamin at Gibeah. There are two indications.
The first is in the verse that describes the brothers’ departure:
“As soon as the morning was light, the men were sent away, they and their asses.” (Gen 44:3)
The Talmud derives a rule of conduct from this verse: a traveler should always set out in daylight and arrive in daylight (Pesachim 2a). This is exactly what the Levite of Gibeah failed to do. His father-in-law held him back day after day. On the last day he urged him once more: “Behold, now the day is drawing toward evening; please stay all night … and tomorrow set out early on your way” (Judg 19:9). This time the Levite refused, and set out late in the day. By the time they reached Jebus, “the day was far spent” (19:11), and “the sun went down upon them near to Gibeah, which belongs to Benjamin” (19:14). Had he left in the morning, as the brothers did, he would never have spent the night in Gibeah.
The second indication is in the object itself. The cup that was hidden in Benjamin’s sack is called a gevia (G-B-Y-E). Within the Torah, the word is used for a drinking cup only in this story. The name of the city where the tribe of Benjamin brought destruction on itself is Gibeah, Giv’ah (G-B-E-H). The two words share the same basic letters. The cup with which the brothers’ curse fell on Benjamin bears the name of the place where it was fulfilled.
But Benjamin Did Nothing Wrong
An obvious objection arises here. Benjamin himself was innocent. He had not taken the cup; Joseph had it put in his sack. Why should a curse spoken by his brothers in ignorance fall on him, or on his descendants centuries later?
The answer, I believe, is that it did not fall on him. Benjamin did not die, because he had done nothing wrong. The curse had no direct effect until the tribe of Benjamin itself sinned. Even then, the men of Benjamin did not die because of the curse. They died because of what they did.
After the outrage at Gibeah, the other tribes did not go to war at once. They first sent a demand to the tribe of Benjamin: “Now therefore hand over the men, the base fellows, who are in Gibeah, that we may put them to death, and put away evil from Israel.” And the text continues: “But the children of Benjamin would not listen to the voice of their brothers the children of Israel” (Judg 20:13). Instead they gathered to defend Gibeah. Without the curse, one might suppose, the outcome could have been different. They could have relented. They could have brought the guilty men to justice and accepted their brothers’ demand. They did not. That stubbornness was their own choice, and their own fault.
I cannot say that I know how this works. But the curse is there in the background, and when circumstances warrant it, it has an effect to some degree. Without personal sin, the curse cannot cause injustice. The same is true of Rachel’s other son. Joseph was sold into slavery, but he did not die, nor, as far as I know, were his descendants radically affected. Even Rachel, the first to be struck, was not entirely innocent. She was the one who had taken the images.
A similar question arises about Moses, and it can be resolved in the same way. In Deuteronomy, Moses says that he was condemned not to enter the land because of the people, in the context of the sin of the spies: “Also the LORD was angry with me because of you, saying: You also shall not go in there” (Deut 1:37). Yet the Book of Numbers gives a different reason, his striking of the rock: “Because you did not believe in Me, to sanctify Me in the eyes of the children of Israel, therefore you shall not bring this assembly into the land which I have given them” (Num 20:12). After the sin of the spies Moses could no longer enter the land. But his life could not be taken until he himself did something wrong. So both statements are true. The decree was made because of the people, and it took effect because of Moses’ own act. In the same way, the curse was spoken by Jacob and his sons, and it took effect only through the sin of Benjamin’s descendants.