Chapter 19: Long-Distance Connections: Other Books, section 2 of 5 Overview of chapter 19 Book contents Previous Next

Ecclesiastes

Tradition holds that the Book of Ecclesiastes, Kohelet in Hebrew, was written by King Solomon, and it is customary to read it on the festival of Sukkot. Sukkot was also the time when, once every seven years, the king read the Torah aloud to the whole nation. This is the commandment of hakhel, “assembling,” set out in Deuteronomy 31:

“At the end of every seven years, in the set time of the year of release, in the feast of tabernacles, when all Israel has come to appear before the LORD your God in the place which He will choose, you shall read this law before all Israel in their hearing. Assemble (hakhel) the people, the men and the women and the little ones, and your stranger who is within your gates, that they may hear, and that they may learn, and fear the LORD your God, and observe to do all the words of this law.” (Deut 31:10–12)

The name Kohelet comes from the same root as hakhel, Q-H-L. One opinion in the midrash holds that Solomon was given this name because his words were spoken at the hakhel assembly. The book itself seems to support this. It is built in part on this passage of the Torah: its beginning echoes the opening of the passage, and its ending echoes the law of hakhel.

The purpose of hakhel. First, a word about what hakhel was for. I once read an article, whose author and source I no longer recall, arguing that hakhel was designed as a reenactment of the giving of the Torah at Sinai. It was held just after the close of the Sabbatical year, when the land lay without produce, much as Israel received the Torah in the desert. Like the gathering at Sinai, it required everyone to be present: men, women, and even little children. I believe there is real evidence for this view.

When Moses recalls the day at Sinai earlier in Deuteronomy, he uses the very same word, hakhel:

”…the day that you stood before the LORD your God in Horeb, when the LORD said to me: ‘Assemble (hakhel) Me the people, and I will make them hear My words, that they may learn to fear Me all the days that they live upon the earth, and that they may teach their children.’” (Deut 4:10)

The command hakhel, “assemble,” occurs in this exact form only four times in the entire Bible: once in Leviticus (8:3), once in Numbers (20:8), and twice in Deuteronomy, here at Sinai and in the law of hakhel (31:12). Elsewhere Moses calls the day of the giving of the Torah “the day of the assembly” (yom ha-kahal, 9:10; 10:4; 18:16).

The two passages also share their language. The law of hakhel gives its purpose in a sequence of five verbs: “that they may hear (yishme’u), and that they may learn (yilmedu), and fear (ve-yare’u) the LORD your God, and observe (ve-shamru) to do (la’asot).” The next verse turns to the children who have not yet known. The verse about Sinai has the first three of the same verbs, in the same order, “hear … learn … fear,” and it too turns to the children. The verses around it complete the set. The verse before it warns, “only take heed to yourself, and keep (u-shmor) your soul diligently” (4:9), and three verses later Moses recalls the covenant God declared at Sinai, “which He commanded you to do (la’asot), the ten words” (4:13). So within a few verses, the account of Sinai has all five verbs of the hakhel law, together with the command hakhel itself.

The verb “learn,” L-M-D, shows how unusual this is. In the Torah it occurs only in Deuteronomy, in sixteen verses. Only one of them, the law of hakhel (31:12), contains all five verbs. The strongest matches after it are all about the giving of the law or the keeping of it. One is the verse about Sinai (4:10). Another opens Moses’ repetition of the Ten Commandments: “Hear, O Israel … that you may learn them, and observe to do them” (5:1), four of the five verbs. The third is the law that the king must write a copy of the Torah and read it all his life, “that he may learn to fear the LORD his God, to keep all the words of this law and these statutes, to do them” (17:19), again four of the five. And it is the king who reads the Torah aloud at hakhel. Each time the assembly at Sinai or the keeping of its law is described, the same chain of words returns. The law of hakhel repeats that chain, and in doing so describes its own purpose: to bring the nation back, once in seven years, to the day it stood at Sinai.

The beginning of Ecclesiastes. The Torah portion that contains the law of hakhel begins with Moses going to speak to the people, and its first subject is his own approaching death:

“And Moses went (va-yelech) and spoke these words to all Israel. And he said to them: ‘I am a hundred and twenty years old this day; I can no more go out and come in (lavo); and the LORD has said to me: You shall not go over this Jordan.’” (Deut 31:1–2)

Death is one of the main themes of Ecclesiastes, and the book opens with a picture of everything going round in circles: the sun, the wind, the rivers, and human beings themselves, generation after generation:

“One generation passes away (holech), and another generation comes (ba); and the earth abides for ever.” (Eccl 1:4)

Moses “went” and could no longer “come.” In Ecclesiastes, the generations “go” and “come.” The verb of going returns again and again in the opening verses, for the sun, the wind and the rivers (1:5–7).

The verb “go” is the headline of the Torah portion. Its first word, va-yelech, “and he went,” gives the portion its name, and the verb returns twice in Moses’ words of encouragement: the LORD your God, “He it is who goes (ha-holech) with you” (31:6, 8).

The end of Ecclesiastes. The close of the book points to the law of hakhel itself:

“And besides the fact that Koheleth was wise, he also taught (limmad) the people (et ha-am) knowledge.” (Eccl 12:9)

In the Torah, as we saw, this verb occurs only in Deuteronomy, and most of its occurrences concern the giving of the law, the teaching of it to one’s children, and hakhel.

“The end of the matter, all having been heard (nishma): fear (yera) God, and keep (shemor) His commandments; for this is the whole man.” (12:13)

The verb “to teach,” from the same root as “learn,” appears within a few verses of these, and the name Kohelet appears with it. Kohelet “taught the people,” just as the king at hakhel was to “assemble the people … that they may learn.” The book’s last words of advice are hear, fear and keep, the verbs of the hakhel law in the same order. And the final verse adds the fifth: “For God will bring every work (ma’aseh) into the judgment” (12:14). The beginning of the book is built on the opening verses of the Torah portion and on its theme of death. The end of the book points to the law of hakhel, and through it to Sinai.

Last revised 12 November 2026