Chapter 23: Does God Exist?, section 3 of 4 Overview of chapter 23 Book contents Previous Next

Answering the Skeptics

Skeptics have offered several replies to this argument, and it is fair to look at the main ones.

The first concerns the reign of Josiah. The book of Kings tells that during repairs to the Temple the high priest Hilkiah announced, “I have found the book of the Law in the house of the LORD” (2 Kings 22:8). Many scholars hold that this book was Deuteronomy, newly written and presented as an ancient discovery. If so, they say, a nation did accept a book it had never known before.

But the account itself says nothing of the kind. Hilkiah speaks of finding the book of the Law, not a book, as of something whose existence was known. When it is read to the king, Josiah tears his garments and says that great is the wrath of the LORD “because our fathers have not listened to the words of this book” (2 Kings 22:13). The fathers could not be blamed for neglecting a book they had never been given. The king’s alarm makes sense only if the law was known, and its obligations recognized, long before. The scholars’ reading assumes that the scroll in the Temple was the only copy in existence and that the nation had kept none of its laws until then. The text assumes the opposite, and nothing outside the text supports the scholars’ view.

The second reply concerns Nehemiah. When the returned exiles kept the festival of Tabernacles in Jerusalem, the book reports that “since the days of Joshua the son of Nun to that day the children of Israel had not done so” (Neh 8:17). Some scholars take this to mean that Tabernacles was a new festival. Yet the book of Ezra reports that the same community had already kept Tabernacles “as it is written” years earlier, when the altar was first rebuilt (Ezra 3:4). The verse in Nehemiah speaks of the manner of the celebration, not of a new institution. Kings uses the same kind of expression about Josiah’s Passover, that “no such passover had been kept from the days of the judges” (2 Kings 23:22), and no one supposes that Passover had never been kept before. More broadly, we must ask why these exiles had come back at all. Why would they rebuild a Temple, restore its offerings and gather to hear the Torah read, if the Torah and its festivals were new to them? People do not make a four-month journey to restore what they never had.

The third reply is the most common: the story grew gradually. No one was ever asked to accept the whole account at once; each generation added a little, and over centuries a modest tradition became the story of the Exodus and Sinai.

This reply misunderstands what the Torah asks people to believe. It is not a report of an experience that might fade or swell in the retelling. It is a body of law: obligations, duties and prohibitions that govern food, work, marriage, the calendar and nearly every part of daily life. Collective memories do fade, and over time a real event may be forgotten or blurred. But there is no known case of a collective memory growing, step by step, into the conviction that one’s entire nation once stood before God and received a demanding and complex code of law that all its members were bound to keep. A dim recollection of some past event is one thing; accepting a whole way of life on the strength of it is another. Nothing comparable has ever been shown to happen, and so the claim that it happened here remains a supposition without any evidence whatsoever.

The same answer meets the fourth reply, that other religions also tell of revelations seen by groups of people. The Torah does not describe a group experience. It describes a nation receiving a mission and a way of life, and it binds every later generation to that mission in the name of what its ancestors saw. That is the claim that, as far as we know, stands alone.

Last revised 14 November 2026