Chapter 23: Does God Exist?, section 2 of 4 Overview of chapter 23 Book contents Previous Next

The Foundation of Belief: Sinai

Many Jewish thinkers have argued for the existence of God by philosophical reasoning, from the order of the world or from the need for a first cause. Yet they agree, in the end, that this is not where Jewish belief rests. Its foundation is the account given in the Torah itself, and above all the giving of the law at Sinai. Maimonides, the greatest of the Jewish philosophers, states it plainly: Israel did not believe in Moses because of the wonders he performed, since wonders can be doubted, but because of what happened at Sinai, “for our eyes saw, and not a stranger’s” (Laws of the Foundations of the Torah 8:1). What moves a Jew to believe is not science or philosophy. It is the memory of an event experienced by an entire nation at one time.

The Torah is well aware that this memory is its strongest claim, and it says so most directly in Deuteronomy. Moses tells the people, “Only take heed to yourself, and keep your soul diligently, lest you forget the things which your eyes saw… make them known to your children and your children’s children; the day that you stood before the LORD your God in Horeb” (Deut 4:9–10). He insists that the covenant was made “not with our fathers… but with us, all of us who are here alive this day,” and that “the LORD spoke with you face to face on the mountain out of the midst of the fire” (Deut 5:3–4). And he invites the people to search all of history for anything like it: “For ask now about the days past… whether there has been any such thing as this great thing, or has been heard like it? Did a people ever hear the voice of God speaking out of the midst of the fire, as you have heard, and live?” (Deut 4:32–33). The challenge still stands. As far as we know, no other religion has ever rested its claim on a revelation witnessed by a whole nation.

Much of the Torah’s law can be read as a system for keeping this memory alive. The Sabbath is linked to creation and, in Deuteronomy, to the Exodus: “And you shall remember that you were a servant in the land of Egypt” (Deut 5:15). Passover retells the Exodus each year in every Jewish home, and the Mishnah requires each person to see himself as though he had come out of Egypt (Mishnah Pesachim 10:5). Tabernacles (Sukkot) is kept “so that your generations may know that I made the children of Israel dwell in booths, when I brought them out of the land of Egypt” (Lev 23:43), and the Feast of Weeks (Shavuot), in Jewish tradition, marks the giving of the law. The Shema is recited morning and evening, and its last verse reads “I am the LORD your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt” (Num 15:41). The Torah itself is read publicly week after week, from scrolls that last for centuries and are found in every community, often many to a community. These practices are kept in nearly identical form by Jews all over the world, and they have been for as long as there are records. The whole system seems designed so that the Exodus, Sinai and the covenant made there would never be forgotten.

Modern scholarship, of course, largely rejects all of this. It holds that the event at Sinai never took place, that the Torah is not what it claims to be, and that the customs and laws are later inventions. But these are hypotheses, not findings. No evidence shows that Sinai did not happen; the scholarly case rests on interpretations of the text, and, as earlier chapters have shown, those interpretations are mistaken in many respects.

The real question lies elsewhere. Suppose there was no bondage in Egypt, no Exodus and no Sinai, and the whole account was composed centuries later. Then we must explain how an entire nation came to believe it. When was the story first told? What did those who first heard it know? They would have been told that their own ancestors, every family of them, had been slaves in Egypt, had walked out together, and had stood at a mountain and heard God speak. Yet no one among them had ever heard any of this from his parents or grandparents. And they would have been asked not merely to believe it but to change their lives because of it: to rest every seventh day, to keep the festivals, to circumcise their sons, to observe hundreds of laws. A people persuaded in this way that their ancestors underwent experiences of which no memory remained would be without parallel in history.

It is one thing for a single person to announce that he has received a revelation, and for others to choose to believe him. Religions have begun that way many times. It is a very different thing to hand a nation a book and say, in effect: here is what your ancestors saw and were taught; you never heard of it, but begin keeping it anyway. Nor were the Jews a credulous people. Their tradition prizes argument and questioning, and its central texts record disagreement on nearly every page.

Skeptics have offered answers to this, and those who are interested can find them. But this is the point on which believers have rested their faith for thousands of years, and it is the point the Torah itself chose to stress.

Last revised 14 November 2026