Fundamental Questions
In the chapters so far we have looked at the Hebrew Bible from several angles, and each has pointed to the same conclusion: this is a serious book, written with great care and meant to be read with equal care.
We saw first that it has a plan. The opening chapters of Genesis explain why the world went wrong and why a chosen nation was needed, and the rest of the Torah lays out, stage by stage, how that nation is meant to bring blessing to the world. The plan is not stated once and forgotten. It runs through the order of the laws, the course of the narrative, the cycle of the holidays and the history that follows.
We saw next that the book’s internal structure matches its purpose. The divisions of the text, the placement of the laws within the stories, and the countless connections between words and names that tie one passage to another are not ornaments added at the end. They serve the plan. A text built this way does not look like a collection of fragments stitched together by later hands; it looks like one design.
We saw, finally, that later writers took it seriously. The authors of Judges, Samuel, Ruth, Ecclesiastes, Psalms and Isaiah wrote with the Torah before them, borrowing its rare words and unusual phrases and shaping their own accounts to echo it. They treated it not as one book among many but as the book against which events were to be understood.
All of this matters. But none of it, by itself, makes the Bible relevant.
A book can be serious, carefully built and deeply admired and still be the work of human beings only. If there is no God, then the master plan is a plan that someone imagined. The structure is the achievement of a gifted author or school of authors, and the reverence of later writers is reverence for a great human work. We could still admire it, as we admire Homer or Shakespeare. We might even find in it wise ideas worth living by. But it would not be relevant in the sense this book has in mind. Its claim to tell us what the world is for, and what is asked of us in it, would carry no more authority than any other thoughtful person’s opinion.
The Bible itself does not present its message as opinion. It speaks in the name of God. Whether that claim is true is therefore not a side question that can be left to the theologians. It is the question on which everything else rests.
For that reason a book like this one cannot be complete unless it also faces some fundamental questions directly. The first, and the most basic, is whether God exists.
Evidence, Not Proof
Before we begin, it is worth being clear about what the following chapters will not attempt. They will not try to prove that God exists, and the main reason is simple: absolute proof of anything of this kind is never possible.
Consider a deliberately silly claim. Suppose someone insists that the entire universe was created one second ago, complete with our memories, our books, the light from distant stars and the fossils in the rocks. There is no way to prove him wrong. Whatever evidence we bring, a photograph, a diary, the age of a tree, he will answer calmly that this, too, was created a second ago exactly as it is. The claim is absurd, and no one believes it, yet it cannot be refuted. If even this cannot be disproved, it should not surprise us that the larger questions about the world, and about what lies behind it, cannot be settled by proof either.
What we can ask for is evidence, and here a second difficulty appears: how much evidence is enough depends on the matter at hand and on the person weighing it. Legal systems recognize this openly. In many countries a civil case is decided by which side is more likely to be right, while a criminal conviction requires proof beyond reasonable doubt. The stakes are different, so the standard is different. Something similar happens with belief in God. A person raised in a religious home may ask for very strong evidence before concluding that God does not exist. A person raised without belief may ask for an equally strong case before concluding that He does. Each begins from a different place, and each sets the bar accordingly. Neither is being unreasonable; this is how people weigh evidence about everything that matters to them.
There is also a third reason, and it comes from the Jewish tradition itself. Judaism has long held that an absolute proof of God’s existence would run against the very purpose of the world.
The Hebrew word for “world” or “universe” is olam, written with the letters E-L-M. Jewish sources have pointed out that the same letters form a verb meaning to hide, to be hidden, or to be unaware of something. The Torah uses this verb in several places. A law in Leviticus speaks of a case where “the thing is hidden from the eyes of the assembly” (Lev 4:13). A few verses later the same verb describes a man who touched something unclean or swore rashly “and it is hidden from him” (Lev 5:2–4), that is, he did not realize or had forgotten. The suspected wife of Numbers is one whose conduct was “hidden from the eyes of her husband” (Num 5:13). In Deuteronomy a person who finds his neighbor’s lost ox or sheep is told “you may not hide yourself” (Deut 22:3), may not look away and pretend not to see. The sages drew the connection explicitly. When God tells Moses at the burning bush, “This is My name for ever” (Exod 3:15), the Hebrew for “for ever,” le-olam, is written in the scroll without the letter V, so that its letters may also be read le-alem, “to be hidden” (Pesachim 50a). Later Jewish thinkers took the point further: the world, olam, is the place where God is hidden, nelam.
Why should this be so? Earlier in this book we saw that, in Jewish thought, the aim of creation is to give human beings the ability to earn their own reward, and that this is possible only if they truly choose between good and evil. A choice that is forced is not a choice. If God’s existence were palpable and beyond any doubt, as obvious as the sun overhead, no one could seriously choose against Him, and the choice for Him would mean little. For choice to be real, there must be room for doubt. There has to be a way out.
What follows, then, is not a formal proof. It is an account of the reasons why those who believe in God do so: the considerations that lead thoughtful people, many of them well acquainted with science and philosophy, to conclude that the world is not the product of chance alone. The reader is invited to weigh these reasons by whatever standard he thinks fit.