A Planet Fit for Life
The finely tuned rules and forces of the first moment account, in broad outline, for the large-scale shape of the universe. Once the laws were set, the strengths of the forces fixed and the expansion balanced precisely enough, much of what followed was more or less automatic. Matter gathered into galaxies, galaxies into stars, and around many of those stars smaller bodies formed and settled into orbit. Physicists cannot yet explain every step of this, but they understand its general course.
A planet that can support life is another matter. That does not seem to follow automatically at all. For life to arise and endure, a great many conditions have to be met at once, and several of them appear to depend on a good deal of luck. In 2000 the paleontologist Peter Ward and the astronomer Donald Brownlee set out the case in a book called Rare Earth, and others have added to it since. The full list is long. A few examples are enough to show its character.
The earth’s place in the galaxy matters. Near the crowded center of our galaxy, radiation and exploding stars would repeatedly sterilize a planet. Far out at the thin edges, there is too little of the heavier elements needed to build rocky planets and living things. Our solar system lies in a fairly narrow zone between the two.
The kind of star matters. The sun is steady, single, long-lived and of moderate size. Most stars in the galaxy are smaller red dwarfs, which often throw off violent flares, and a planet near enough to one of them to be warm would usually be locked with one face always toward it. Very large stars burn out too quickly for life to develop.
The earth’s distance from the sun matters. Only within a fairly narrow band can water remain liquid on a planet’s surface. Venus, a little closer, is an oven; Mars, a little farther, is a frozen desert. The earth’s orbit is also nearly circular, so it does not swing from scorching heat to deep cold each year.
The earth’s size matters. Its gravity is strong enough to hold an atmosphere and oceans of water, which a smaller body like Mars largely lost. A much larger planet might hold so thick an atmosphere, or be so covered in water, that life as we know it would be impossible. The amount of water matters too: enough for oceans, but not so much that no dry land would appear.
The moon matters. It is unusually large in relation to its planet, and it was probably formed by a chance collision early in the earth’s history. Its pull steadies the tilt of the earth’s axis. Without it, calculations suggest, the tilt would wander widely over long periods, bringing extreme and unstable changes of climate.
The earth’s interior matters. Its molten iron core generates a magnetic field that shields the surface from the stream of particles flowing from the sun; Mars, without such a field, saw much of its atmosphere stripped away. The slow movement of the earth’s crust, known as plate tectonics, recycles carbon between rock and air and acts over millions of years as a kind of thermostat, keeping the climate within livable bounds. No other planet is known to have it.
Even the air we breathe was not simply given. The early earth had no free oxygen in its atmosphere. Oxygen accumulated only after tiny living organisms had been producing it for hundreds of millions of years, and only then could the ozone layer form to screen out the sun’s most harmful rays. A planet fit for complex life was, in part, made so by life itself.
Each condition on its own may not be rare. The difficulty is that all of them had to be met together, and for billions of years.
Many scientists disagree with the rare-earth view. They point to the enormous size of the universe, with billions of galaxies each containing billions of stars, and argue that among so many, earth-like planets must be common. Astronomers have now discovered more than six thousand planets around other stars, and some are close to the earth in size and lie in the zone where liquid water is possible. But no planet has yet been found that matches the earth in all these respects, and no life of any kind has been found anywhere beyond the earth. That such places exist may be true; so far it is a belief, not a finding. Some who have tried to calculate the odds conclude that a planet like ours is very rare indeed.
Here again, then, the evidence points the same way. A planet able to support life, and to support it for the billions of years that the development of life required, is not easily explained. It can be waved away by appealing to the size of the universe, but it cannot be said that science has shown it to be ordinary. Certainly nothing here shows that we have no need of God. It may well be that here, too, getting it right required Him.