What the Findings Imply
These discoveries are not evidence that God does not exist. If anything, they point the other way. At the very moment of the universe’s beginning, everything needed for it to unfold into stars and planets and living things was already in place: the rules, the forces, their strengths and the delicate balances among them, all set within extraordinarily narrow limits. This is what one would expect if the universe were made with a purpose. It is much harder to explain if it were not.
Many scientists have felt the force of this. The physicist Paul Davies, in God and the New Physics, describes how these findings led many physicists at least to take seriously the question of God’s existence, and some to believe in Him. Few of them became religious in any traditional sense. But for many, it was no longer obvious that there is no God, as it may once have seemed. Fred Hoyle, the astronomer whose prediction about carbon we met earlier, was no believer, yet he wrote that a commonsense reading of the facts suggests that a superintellect had “monkeyed with physics.”
Of course many scientists still do not believe in God. But the findings place a question before them that they must answer: why does everything seem so finely tuned? Some have proposed explanations of their own, and they may be right or wrong. Yet every such explanation is an attempt to account for something the evidence itself has raised. The burden now rests on those who deny that the universe was designed to show why it looks so much as though it were.
For the believer, the conclusion is simple. In this area science has found nothing that diminishes belief in God. On the contrary, it has strengthened it. The psalmist wrote, “The heavens declare the glory of God, and the firmament shows His handiwork” (Ps 19:2). He could not have known how precisely the heavens were made. Modern physics has given his words a depth he could not have imagined.
The Skeptics’ Replies
Those who do not see design in these findings have offered several explanations. Three are heard most often, and each deserves a look.
The first is known as the anthropic principle. It says that we should not be surprised to find the universe suited to life, because if it were not, we would not be here to notice. Only a universe that permits observers can ever be observed. This is true, but it does not explain very much. The philosopher John Leslie offered an illustration. A man is to be executed by a firing squad of fifty trained marksmen. The shots ring out, and he finds himself alive and unhurt: every one of them has missed. He might say, “Of course they missed; had they not, I would not be here to wonder about it.” But no sensible person would leave it at that. He would want to know why fifty marksmen missed, and he would suspect that it was no accident. That we can only find ourselves in a life-permitting universe does not tell us why such a universe exists.
The second explanation is the multiverse. Perhaps, it is suggested, our universe is only one of an enormous number of universes, perhaps an infinite number, each with its own settings for the forces and constants of nature. Most would be lifeless, but among so many a few would happen to have the right values, and we live in one of those. If there are enough tickets, someone is bound to win the lottery.
This idea is taken seriously by some physicists, and certain theories of the early universe can be read as allowing for it. But it has important weaknesses. No other universe has ever been observed, and by most accounts none ever can be, since they lie wholly beyond any possible contact with our own. Indeed, they lie beyond observation by definition: anything we could ever observe would be part of our own universe. Nor could we know what the other universes are like. The explanation works only if nearly all of them are lifeless, so that ours is one lucky winner among countless losers. If they were all as well suited to life as ours, nothing would have been explained; the puzzle would simply have been multiplied. The multiverse is therefore not a finding of science but a proposal about what lies beyond its reach. It also asks us to accept the existence of a vast, perhaps infinite, number of unseen worlds in order to avoid the existence of one unseen God, an odd trade for those who prefer the simplest explanation. And it does not end the question; it moves it. Whatever process produces these universes must itself run according to laws, and those laws must be of exactly the right kind to produce universes with varied settings, among them some that permit life. We are left asking where those laws came from.
The third explanation is a hope for the future: perhaps a deeper theory, not yet discovered, will show that the forces and constants could not have had any values other than the ones they have. Then there would be nothing to explain. This may happen; no one can say. But it is a hope, not a result. And if it did happen, it would only shift the question once more. We would then want to know why the deepest laws of nature happen to be laws that make a universe capable of stars, planets and life, rather than any of the countless other laws that could have governed a lifeless universe or none at all.
Each of these replies may be held by thoughtful people. None of them is a discovery of science, and none removes the question that the findings raise. They are different ways of answering it, and the reader is free to judge which answer he finds most reasonable.