From Simple to Complex
Even once life had begun, the road from the simplest living cell to the variety of life today was far from smooth. The theory of evolution holds that it was traveled in small steps, each a slight improvement on the last, accumulated over immense spans of time. When we look at what actually had to happen, the steps turn out to be anything but small.
The first great divide runs between two kinds of cells. The simplest living things, bacteria and their relatives, are made of what biologists call prokaryotic cells. The cells of animals, plants, fungi and many single-celled organisms are of a different kind, called eukaryotic. The difference between them is something like the difference between a one-family house and a skyscraper. A typical eukaryotic cell is about ten times as wide as a bacterium and perhaps a thousand times its volume. But size is the least of it. Its DNA is kept inside a nucleus, a separate compartment with its own double wall, pierced by elaborate gateways, each built from hundreds of protein molecules, that control what goes in and out. It contains mitochondria, small power plants with their own DNA, which supply most of its energy. It has an internal network of membranes where proteins are made, finished, sorted and shipped to where they are needed. It has a framework of fibers that gives it shape, lets it move, and serves as a system of tracks along which tiny motor proteins carry cargo from place to place. When it divides it does not simply split in two but performs a carefully choreographed sequence in which its chromosomes are copied, lined up and pulled apart. Even the way it reads its own genes is more complicated, involving a machine of well over a hundred proteins that cuts and splices each message before it is used.
How did the one become the other? Most biologists accept that mitochondria were once free-living bacteria that came to live inside another cell, and this is a reasonable idea. But it explains only one feature among many. The earliest eukaryotic cells known appear in the fossil record more than a billion years after the first bacteria, and when they appear they already have the full set of equipment: nucleus, mitochondria, internal membranes, framework and all. No living cells or fossils show the stages in between. The microbes thought to be the closest living relatives of the first eukaryotes, discovered only in the last decade or so, carry a few genes resembling eukaryotic ones, but they have no nucleus and none of the other structures. How the skyscraper was built from the house is, by the admission of those who study it, one of the great unsolved problems of biology.
The next divide is just as wide. To go from a single complex cell to an animal, cells must learn to stick together, to signal to one another, to divide their labor so that some become muscle, some nerve, some skin and some blood, and to follow a precise plan that turns a single fertilized egg into a body with every part in its proper place. Some cells must even be programmed to die at the right moment, as the cells between the fingers of an embryo do. None of these abilities is any use without the others.
And when we turn to the fossil record, change does not appear in the slow and steady steps the theory leads us to expect. Again and again, new forms appear suddenly. The most famous example is the Cambrian explosion, about five hundred and forty million years ago, when most of the major groups of animals, each with its own basic body plan, appear within a span of perhaps twenty million years, a short time by the standards of geology, with little sign of their ancestors in the rocks below. Darwin knew of this and admitted that he could not explain it. Flowering plants, which today cover most of the earth’s land, appear in the fossil record relatively suddenly and spread with great speed; Darwin called their origin an “abominable mystery.” The pattern is general enough that in 1972 two leading paleontologists, Niles Eldredge and Stephen Jay Gould, proposed a revision of the theory to account for it: species, they observed, tend to remain much the same for long periods and then change, or are replaced, quickly. Whatever the explanation, the record shows giant leaps, not small steps.
The theory of evolution claims to explain the whole of life, from the first cell to the human being. It is a reasonable explanation, and small changes within living populations are well documented: bacteria become resistant to drugs, the beaks of birds change in size from one dry season to the next. But it has never been shown that changes of this kind, added together, are capable of producing a new organ, a new type of cell or a new body plan. Scientists have not watched it happen, they have not made it happen in the laboratory, and they cannot calculate that it would happen in the time available. For the major transitions in the history of life, the explanation is an assumption, not a demonstration.
It is often said that science no longer needs God to explain anything. This is far from true. We know a great deal, and we can explain some of it. But we are nowhere near able to explain it all, at least not with evidence, experiments and work in the laboratory. On the greatest questions of all, how the universe came to be suited to life, how the earth came to be able to support it, how life began, and how it came to take the forms it has, science offers hypotheses and hopes, not answers. There is room for God in all of them.
Read for Yourself
This is not the place for a full discussion of any of these subjects, and the author does not claim to be the right person to provide one. Each of them, the fine-tuning of the universe, the rarity of the earth, the origin of life and its development, has been the subject of a vast literature, and the reader who wishes to pursue them will find no shortage of material.
One piece of advice is worth giving, however. Do not rely on the textbook account. Textbooks, and still more the popular articles and documentaries through which most people learn about science, tend to present the subject as settled, with the difficulties smoothed over and the open questions left out. Their descriptions are often simplified to the point of being misleading, sometimes out of date, and occasionally simply wrong. Read the other side as well. There are scientists and philosophers, some of them religious and some not, who have raised serious challenges to the accepted account. You may not agree with all their points. But you will find that enough of them are valid to diminish greatly the public image of science as a body of knowledge that has explained, or is about to explain, everything.
It has not. Science has achieved a great deal, and nothing said here is meant to belittle it. But it cannot explain everything, and on the deepest questions it is further from an explanation than its public face suggests. It is very possible that many things cannot be explained at all without a God who created us all.