Chapter 25: Basic Beliefs and Attitudes, section 1 of 4 Overview of chapter 25 Book contents Previous Next

What Judaism Requires

Before turning to the question of whether science and the Bible are at odds with each other, a few more points must be made.

Judaism has basic principles of belief. They are not listed as such in the Torah. They were set out clearly by later writers, though they rest on earlier sources and on the understanding of the Bible handed down through the generations. The best known list is that of Maimonides, who counted thirteen principles of faith. Among them are the existence of God, His unity, prophecy, the unique prophecy of Moses, the divine origin of the Torah, and the principle that the Torah we have today is the same Torah given to Moses.

A later work on the subject, the Sefer ha-Ikkarim (The Book of Principles) of Rabbi Joseph Albo, written in Spain in the early fifteenth century, reduces the principles to three: the existence of God, the giving of the Torah by God, and reward for good and punishment for evil. These contain essentially the same ideas as Maimonides’ list. Albo treats the rest as branches that grow out of these three roots.

Albo deals directly with the question of creation, one of the subjects most often thought to bring the Torah into conflict with science, and one to which we will return in the next chapter. He discusses an ancient view, held by Plato, that some form of primeval matter existed eternally, and that God’s acts of creation consisted of shaping the world out of that matter, not of creating it from nothing. Albo holds that creation from nothing is the correct view and the one the Torah teaches. Yet he does not count it among the fundamental principles of the faith. More than that, he holds that a person who believes in the Torah and its principles, but who reaches a mistaken conclusion from his reading of the text, is not a heretic. He may have erred, and his error may need atonement, but he remains within the faith.

Not every authority agrees. Maimonides, in his code of law, appears to count anyone who denies that God alone is the first cause of all things among the heretics (Laws of Repentance 3:7), and Albo himself acknowledges that Maimonides took a stricter view. Even so, Maimonides wrote elsewhere that the Platonic view, had it been proved, could be reconciled with the Torah by interpreting the relevant verses accordingly (Guide of the Perplexed II:25). Despite such statements, as a practical matter, many in traditional communities today would regard any departure from the literal reading of the creation account with deep suspicion.

The basic point, however, stands. According to a respected authority within the tradition, a misreading of the creation account, so long as it does not touch the three fundamental principles, is not a grave matter. It is at most a mistake, with relatively minor consequences, if any. Judaism’s belief in God does not depend on any particular understanding of whether creation came from nothing or otherwise.

The author is not familiar enough with Christian thought on this matter to speak for it, and leaves that to others.

The Tradition’s Own Readers

One can also find, among famous and traditionally accepted authors, statements showing that they were willing to read the creation account in light of what the world itself revealed.

When the fossil remains of great extinct animals were first being discovered in the nineteenth century, Rabbi Israel Lipschitz, author of the Tiferet Yisrael, a commentary on the Mishnah held in high regard to this day, took up the question in an essay printed with his commentary. He did not see in these discoveries any threat to the biblical account. On the contrary, he pointed to the teaching of the Midrash that God had built worlds and destroyed them before creating the present one (Bereshit Rabbah 3:7), and suggested that these creatures belonged to an earlier world.

Much earlier, Don Isaac Abarbanel, the great fifteenth-century statesman and commentator, discussed the firmament that the Torah describes on the second day as dividing “the waters which were under the firmament from the waters which were above” (Gen 1:7). He cites an interpretation according to which this firmament was some kind of division within the ocean itself. Abarbanel dismisses it out of hand: one should not impose on the text a reading that contradicts what we see with our own eyes.

There are many such examples in Jewish sources. Maimonides’ son, Rabbi Abraham, made a related point explicitly. The sages of the Talmud, he wrote, were the masters of the Torah, but on medicine, natural science and astronomy they spoke from the knowledge of their own time, and we are not obliged to accept what they said on such matters merely because of their greatness.

The great commentators did not regard the Torah and the observed world as rivals. When a reading of the text conflicted with what could plainly be seen, they did not deny the evidence; they looked again at the reading.

Last revised 14 November 2026