The Bible and Science: Creation
The ages of the early generations trouble some readers, but the sharpest conflict between science and the Bible lies elsewhere. Even if science has not shown that God does not exist, has it not shown that the Bible is wrong? The conflict is met first, and most sharply, in the opening lines of the Torah, the account of creation. And the most obvious problem there is the time frame: the Torah describes all of creation as taking place in six days.
We will come to that question shortly. First, a few points about the account itself are in order.
The Torah begins, “In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth” (Gen 1:1). It then describes the state of things at that early stage: “Now the earth was unformed and void, and darkness was upon the face of the deep; and the spirit of God hovered over the face of the waters” (Gen 1:2). Only then, in the third verse, does God speak for the first time: “And God said: ‘Let there be light.’ And there was light.” From here on, every act of creation follows the same pattern. First comes a pronouncement by God, “And God said,” and then the thing itself comes into being or is stated as being formed.
The first two verses do not follow that pattern. There is no “And God said” before the creation of heaven and earth. Because of this, an ancient disagreement arose over how to read them. It goes back close to two thousand years and is recorded in the Midrash. One view reads the opening verses as an introduction: I am about to tell you how God created heaven and earth, which at first were in such and such a state. On this reading the account proper begins with the creation of light, and light was the first thing created. The other view holds that the opening verse describes an actual first act: heaven and earth were created first, and light came afterward. The disagreement did not die out. More than a thousand years later, both positions appear in the great commentaries on the Torah. Rashi argues that the first verse does not tell us what was created first. Nachmanides holds that it describes the creation, out of nothing, of the basic matter from which all else was formed.
Each reading has its difficulties. If the first two verses are only an introduction, then the Torah never actually states that the earth was created. The second day already speaks of dividing the waters, presumably the waters that covered the earth, but the text does not say where they came from. It is a question we will return to. The other reading has its own problems, which the commentators discuss at length.
Consider, though, how the Midrash puts the first view. Rabbi Yehudah and Rabbi Nehemiah disagreed: Rabbi Yehudah said that light was created first, Rabbi Nehemiah that the world was created first (Bereshit Rabbah 3:1). (A different dispute, between the schools of Shammai and Hillel, concerns whether heaven or earth came first; Chagigah 12a.) According to the first opinion, then, light came before the universe itself, and only afterward was the rest made from it. Does that sound familiar? It is very close to what modern science says: the universe began with a sudden burst of energy, out of which everything else formed.
One might object that this is reading modern ideas into an ancient text. Light, after all, is not the same thing as the energy of the Big Bang; visible light is only a narrow band in the broad range of radiation that physicists call electromagnetic. The early universe was filled with radiation of that kind, but mostly at energies far beyond what the eye can see. Yet the same ancient tradition says something remarkable about the light of creation. The Talmud teaches that it was far more powerful than the light we know, so that by it one could see from one end of the world to the other, and that God hid it away for the future (Chagigah 12a). The sages knew nothing of electromagnetism and nothing of the many forms of radiation that science has since discovered. But their tradition held that the light of the first day was not the light we see now. It was a different and far stronger light, which no longer shines in the form in which it was created.