Nachmanides and the First Substance
Nachmanides, who holds that the first verse describes an actual act of creation, adds something more. As we saw, he opens his comment on that verse by saying that the account of creation is a deep secret, known only through the tradition handed down from Moses at Sinai. He then explains what he can. God, he says, first brought forth out of absolute nothing an extremely fine substance, with no physical body, but with the power to take on form and to pass from potential into actuality. After that God created nothing more. Everything else was formed and fashioned out of that first substance. How small was it? In the Hebrew commentary Nachmanides calls it only “very fine.” But Rabbi Charles Chavel, in his annotated edition, points out that in one of Nachmanides’ sermons it is described as smaller than a mustard seed, the traditional image for the smallest thing imaginable. The physicist Gerald Schroeder, who has written widely on the Torah and science, puts it this way: according to Nachmanides, the universe at its beginning was smaller than a grain of mustard.
Why, then, does Nachmanides speak of two first substances, one for the heavens and one for the earth? What follows is my own speculation; there is no way to know it for certain. Nachmanides had received a tradition, a “secret” about creation, that everything began with an extremely small and fine substance holding within it the potential for all that would follow. He also held, as we have seen, that the first verse of the Torah describes an actual act of creation. That verse names two things, the heaven and the earth. Holding both positions, he had to fit the tradition he had received to the verse as he read it. So he gave each of the two a first substance of its own.
Suppose instead that we take the other view, that the opening verses are an introduction and that the first act of creation was “Let there be light.” Then we can take the principle Nachmanides taught, a single, unimaginably small beginning containing the potential for everything, and apply it to the light. The result fits what science describes even more closely: one beginning, a burst of energy far more powerful than any light we know, from which everything else came.
Schroeder’s reading should not simply be set aside, however. It too has real content. According to science, the burst of energy with which the universe began did not appear within an existing space and time. Space and time began with it, and matter followed within the smallest fraction of a second. If so, the opening verses and “Let there be light” may be speaking about the same event from two directions. The opening verses give us an early picture of the state of the universe. “Let there be light” tells us how it came to be. In that sense both views in the Midrash are right, and both speak of the same thing: one of the utterance that brought everything into being, the other of what that utterance produced.
Read this way, the words of the first verse take on a definite meaning. “Heaven” would be space itself. It is worth noticing that the verse does not mention the sun, the moon or the stars; those come only on the fourth day. “Earth,” eretz, would then mean not our planet but matter. That is less strange than it may sound. The Midrash already links eretz with ratz, to run (Bereshit Rabbah 5:8). Matter, as physics has discovered, is never at rest. Its particles are in constant motion, even within the nucleus of the atom, and the picture of the atom that many of us learned in school is of a tiny center with electrons racing around it.
The second verse would then continue in much the way Schroeder reads it. “The earth was unformed and void”: the early matter of the universe was tohu, without form or structure. Science tells us that it took time, some hundreds of thousands of years, before even the simplest atoms could form, and far longer before there were stars and planets. Whether the “waters” of the same verse can also be fitted to this picture I do not know. Physicists describe the early universe as filled with a hot, glowing plasma, which behaves in some ways like a fluid, and one could see in this an image of something like water. But this may be stretching the text too far.
There is another possibility, and it may be the better one. On the reading I have followed, in which light was the first thing created, the Torah never says that the earth itself was created. Perhaps that is exactly what the opening verses supply. They serve as an introduction, and in the course of introducing the account they tell us that the earth existed and what state it was in: unformed and void, and covered with water. If so, the introductory verses and the account proper are not two separate things. The first tells us where things stood, the second how they came about. This also removes the need for two first substances. There was one beginning, the light, and from it came both the heavens and the earth.
I should say plainly that in proposing this I am disagreeing with Nachmanides, and that is not something to be done lightly. His tradition and his authority are far greater than any suggestion of mine. But I am not setting aside what he taught, only the way he fitted it to the verse. The heart of his teaching, that everything began from something unimaginably small that contained the potential for all that would follow, remains. And Nachmanides himself, as we saw, tells us that the opening verses cannot be understood without what was handed down orally alongside them.
Water, Land and Life
Consider next the description of the early earth. The Torah describes it as covered entirely by water, “the face of the deep,” until God gathered the waters into one place and dry land appeared (Gen 1:9). Other ancient peoples also told of primeval waters, but in their stories the waters were usually gods, and the world arose out of their struggles. In Genesis the waters are simply part of the created world, and the sequence is plain: first an earth covered by water, then the appearance of land. This is close to the picture that many geologists now hold, in which the early earth was largely or entirely covered by ocean, and the continents rose above the sea only later.
Finally, consider the order in which life appears. The Torah describes it in stages: first plants, including trees that bear fruit; then the creatures of the sea and the birds; then the animals of the land; and last of all, human beings. If we read this as describing the kinds of living things that exist today, rather than their remote ancestors, the order matches what science describes to a striking degree. Flowering plants, which include nearly all the fruit trees, grains and grasses we know, spread across the earth before the other groups did. Modern fish and modern birds then underwent their great expansion at roughly the same time. The mammals we know today, among them the cattle and other grazing animals of the land, followed. And human beings came last of all. Some of this could perhaps be guessed by anyone thinking about the matter logically. But it is still a definite sequence, and it shows a degree of accuracy one would not necessarily expect from an ancient account written with no knowledge of what science would one day find.