Chapter 24: What Science Claims, section 4 of 5 Overview of chapter 24 Book contents Previous Next

The Origin of Life

Of all the discoveries of modern science, none did more to shake belief in God than the theory of evolution. The reason is not hard to see. For centuries, living things had been the strongest evidence that thinkers could point to. The eye, the wing, the hand and the countless ways in which every creature is suited to its life seemed to show beyond question that they had been designed. In 1802 the English clergyman William Paley compared a living body to a watch found lying on a heath: no one would suppose the watch had assembled itself, and the body is far more intricate than any watch. Then, in 1859, Charles Darwin published On the Origin of Species, and in 1871 argued that human beings share their ancestry with the apes. It now seemed that living things had shaped themselves, slowly and without any guiding hand, and that the strongest argument for God had been taken away. Few scientific ideas have had so profound an effect on how people think about religion.

But here too matters are far less simple than they are usually made to appear. Before we can speak of how one form of life developed into another, there must first be life, and on that question science has much less to say than most people suppose.

A single living cell is the most complex thing known. Even the simplest bacterium is not a bag of chemicals but a working factory. It is enclosed by a membrane that lets some substances in and keeps others out. Inside it stores its instructions in DNA, a long molecule whose sequence of chemical letters spells out how to build every part of the cell. It reads those instructions and copies them into a related molecule, RNA. It carries the RNA to a machine called the ribosome, itself built of dozens of separate parts, which reads the message three letters at a time and assembles proteins from twenty kinds of building blocks called amino acids, linked one by one in exactly the right order. It folds those proteins into precise shapes, so that each can do its job. It produces and stores energy using, among other things, a protein that works as a tiny rotating motor. And it copies all of this, the instructions together with the machinery, whenever it divides.

How little can a cell get by with? Scientists have tried to find out by stripping bacteria down to the bare minimum. In 2016 a team led by Craig Venter produced a synthetic cell with fewer genes than any free-living organism found in nature: 473 genes, containing more than half a million letters of DNA. For about a third of those genes, the researchers did not know what they did, only that the cell could not live without them. That is the smallest working cell anyone has been able to make, and it was made by copying and trimming an existing one, not by building one from scratch.

At the heart of the cell lies a puzzle often compared to the chicken and the egg. DNA holds the instructions for making proteins, but DNA cannot read or copy itself; that work is done by proteins. Proteins do the work, but they cannot be made without the instructions in DNA and the machinery that reads them, which is itself made of proteins and RNA. Each depends on the other. Neither is any use alone. It is hard to see how either could have come first.

There are other difficulties. The building blocks of life come in two mirror-image forms, like left and right hands. Living things use only one form of amino acid and only one form of sugar in their DNA and RNA. Ordinary chemistry, left to itself, produces both forms in equal amounts, and a mixture of the two will not build working molecules. Then there is the question of the instructions themselves. A typical protein is a chain of a few hundred amino acids, and only a tiny fraction of all possible chains fold into anything useful. The cell’s information had to come from somewhere.

In 1953 the chemist Stanley Miller passed electric sparks through a mixture of gases meant to imitate the early earth’s atmosphere and found that some amino acids formed. The experiment was greeted with great excitement, and many expected the rest of the story to follow soon. It did not. The early atmosphere is now thought to have been different from the one Miller used. More importantly, a few amino acids are about as far from a living cell as a pile of bricks is from a working city.

The best-known attempt to break the chicken-and-egg circle is called the “RNA world.” In the 1980s it was discovered that some RNA molecules can do jobs normally done by proteins, speeding up chemical reactions. Perhaps, then, the first life was built of RNA alone, which could both carry instructions and do work, and DNA and proteins came later. The idea is attractive, but it remains a hypothesis, and it has many difficulties of its own. The building blocks of RNA are hard to make without the help of living cells, and one of them, the sugar ribose, breaks down quickly. Long RNA chains tend to fall apart in water. In 2026 researchers reported a small RNA that could make a copy of itself, but only in separate steps under special laboratory conditions, with building blocks supplied by the experimenters, and with a yield of about one copy in five hundred after seventy-two days. Nothing yet comes close to copying itself unaided in the way the hypothesis requires. And even if an RNA world existed, it would still have had to give rise somehow to the system of DNA, proteins and the genetic code that all life uses today.

The honest position, which most researchers in the field would accept, is that no one knows how life began. There are hypotheses, and there is a great deal of laboratory work, but there is no account of how a living cell could arise from non-living chemicals. It may be that we will never know.

Then there is the question of time. The earth is about four and a half billion years old. For its first few hundred million years it was hot and heavily bombarded by debris from space. Yet clear signs of living organisms appear in rocks some three and a half billion years old, and there are disputed signs older still. Life, in other words, seems to have appeared almost as soon as the earth could support it. If its origin was so improbable, it happened against all odds, and with remarkable speed.

There is one more problem. As we saw before, the oxygen in the atmosphere, and the ozone layer that protects the surface, were produced by living things over hundreds of millions of years. Complex life as we know it could not exist without them. So it was not enough for life to begin. A particular kind of life had to arise, one that could capture sunlight and release oxygen, by a process among the most intricate in all of biology, and it had to flourish long enough to transform the planet. Only then could the earth become a home for the rest of life.

We will not here go on to the question of how life, once it existed, developed into the many forms we know today. It is enough to see that the very first step, the step before evolution can even begin, remains unexplained and, by all present indications, extremely hard to explain. It is certainly not something that science has shown can happen without God. Here too, it may be that only He can explain it.

Last revised 14 November 2026