Chapter 27: The Puzzle of the Tabernacle, section 7 of 9 Overview of chapter 27 Book contents Previous Next

The Order Explained

We can now return to the question with which this chapter began: why does the first account of the Tabernacle present its parts in such a puzzling order?

The answer does not depend on anything we have said about the sefirot. What that discussion does show is that the Tabernacle and the human being share a common foundation. They are built on the same plan. If so, one might expect the making of the one to mirror the making of the other.

In practice, the Tabernacle was built the way anyone would build it. The building came first, then the vessels, in a sensible order. That is the order of the accounts that describe the actual work. But the first account, which sets out the rules for making the Tabernacle, follows a different order. To strengthen the resemblance between the Tabernacle and the human being, it presents the parts in the order in which a human being is formed in the womb. The match is remarkably close.

The Head in the Womb

Consider how the head of a human embryo develops.

The brain comes first. In the third week after conception, a thin plate of tissue appears along the back of the embryo. It folds into a tube, and its front end becomes the brain. The first vessel in the Torah’s account is the ark, which corresponds to the brain.

Next come the eyes. They do not form separately and then connect to the brain. They grow out of the brain itself, as two small pouches pushing outward from its front end, near the end of the third week. The retina of the eye is, in fact, a part of the brain. The next two vessels in the Torah’s account are the table and the menorah, which correspond to the eyes. They stood just outside the Holy of Holies, separated from the ark only by the veil, and joined to it, as we saw, by the poles of the ark that pressed against it.

Until this point there is no distinct head. The embryo is a single, undivided body. Then, in the fourth week, the embryo folds, and the head begins to take shape as a separate region, large in proportion to the rest. In the Torah’s account, after the table and the menorah comes the building, which corresponds to the skull.

Only after the head takes shape does the mouth appear. It forms as a hollow in the underside of the head, created by the folding of the head itself. In the Torah’s account, after the building comes the outer altar, which corresponds to the mouth, and then the courtyard, whose hangings surround everything, as the skin and the soft tissues of the face develop around the head.

And the nose? At first it does not exist as a separate organ. The nose and the mouth begin as a single cavity. In the fifth week two small pits appear above the mouth, and they deepen and open into it. For weeks afterward the nose and the mouth remain one open space. Only between about the seventh and the twelfth week do the two halves of the palate grow toward each other and fuse, separating the nose from the mouth. The nose becomes a distinct organ at the very end of the process. In the Torah’s account, the incense altar, which corresponds to the nose, is described last, after the clothing of the priests and the ceremony of their consecration, long after all the other vessels.

The relationship between the two altars confirms the match. The mouth and the nose begin as one cavity and only later divide. In the Tabernacle, the vessels that correspond to them are the only two of the same kind: both are altars. They are the same thing in two forms, as the mouth and the nose are one cavity divided in two.

What of the ears? The basin, which corresponds to them, is not part of the first account at all. It appears afterward, in a separate speech. It would be reasonable, then, for it to stand outside the sequence that the first speech describes. And there is something fitting in this. The ear does not grow out of the brain as the eye does, or out of the cavity of the mouth as the nose does. Its inner part forms from a separate patch of tissue on the surface of the embryo, and its outer part forms from tissue in the region of the neck. The external ears begin low on the sides of the neck and move upward to their final place only gradually. Of all the organs of the head, the ear is the one that comes from elsewhere.

Why the embryo develops in this order is a separate question, and it does not matter here. The point is that the puzzling order of the first account, which seems to make no sense as a description of how to build a building, is best explained as the order in which a human head is formed.

Last revised 15 November 2026