Chapter 27: The Puzzle of the Tabernacle, section 8 of 9 Overview of chapter 27 Book contents Previous Next

Could the Ancients Have Known?

Could an ancient author have known this sequence? Much of it, especially at the start, cannot be seen with the naked eye. In the third and fourth weeks the embryo is only a few millimeters long. The appearance of the brain, the outgrowth of the eyes from it, and the folding that gives shape to the head can be followed only with a microscope. They were first worked out by the embryologists of the nineteenth century.

The ancients did study embryos, by opening hens’ eggs and by examining miscarriages. Aristotle followed the development of the chick and concluded that the heart forms first, because it is the first thing that can be seen moving: a red, beating speck on the third day. The Talmud describes the appearance of a fetus of about forty days, with its eyes, nostrils and mouth (Niddah 25a). A fetus of that age can be seen with the naked eye, and the closing of the palate, which comes later still, could in principle have been observed in a miscarriage. But the earliest sequence was hidden, and the most influential scientific view of the ancient world, Aristotle’s, began not with the brain but with the heart. Interestingly, the Talmud records a dispute on this very question. One view holds that the embryo is formed beginning with its head, and another, that of Abba Shaul, that it is formed beginning from its navel (Yoma 85a). The Torah’s order agrees with the first view, and with what modern science has found.

A similar debate is recorded in the Charaka Samhita, one of the classics of ancient Indian medicine. Its sages proposed in turn that the first part to form is the head, or the heart, the navel, the hands and feet, or the organs of sense. One of them, Marici Kashyapa, held that the question cannot be answered at all, because no one can see it.

The order of the first account has puzzled readers for centuries, and here is an explanation that accounts for it step by step: the brain, then the eyes, then the head, then the mouth, and finally, after a long interval, the nose. At the very least, the match is remarkable.

The Order of Creation

The Tabernacle, we said earlier, is a miniature world as well as a miniature person. If the order of the first account follows the formation of a human being, we may ask whether it also follows the formation of the world. It appears that it does.

The first vessel is the ark, which held the tablets of the law. The sages teach that the Torah existed before the world was created: it is listed among the things that were created before the world (Pesachim 54a), and the Midrash says that God looked into the Torah and created the world by it, as an architect consults his plan (Genesis Rabbah 1:1). The account of the Tabernacle begins, as creation began, with the Torah.

Next come the table and the menorah, in that order. The table, as Abarbanel observed, corresponds to the stars, and the menorah to the sun and the planets. Modern astronomy has found that this is the order in which they came into being. The first stars formed within a few hundred million years of the beginning of the universe. The sun and its planets formed much later, about four and a half billion years ago, more than nine billion years after the first stars. The sun is not one of the original stars. It formed from a cloud of gas that contained heavier elements, which could only have been made inside earlier stars that had already lived and died. To the ancient eye, the sun, the moon and the stars all seemed to belong to a single moment of creation, and the Torah itself describes them together (Gen 1:16). That the stars came first and the sun later is knowledge of the twentieth century.

The building has no clear counterpart in this sequence. But after the building comes the outer altar, which represents the earth. The earth took shape out of the material left over from the formation of the sun, and in its early ages it was hot and violent, reaching its settled form only over a long period.

Last of all comes the incense altar, which represents the atmosphere. Here too the order matches. The earth has had some kind of atmosphere for most of its history, but not the one we breathe. Its early air contained almost no oxygen. Oxygen began to accumulate only about two and a half billion years ago, released by the first living things, and the atmosphere did not reach anything like its present form until perhaps half a billion years ago. The air as we know it, the air that carries fragrance, is the last of these to take its final form, just as the incense altar is the last vessel in the first account.

The basin, which represents the seas, is not part of this sequence. As we saw, it stands outside the first speech altogether, commanded separately afterward, and it need not fit the order that the first speech describes.

The order of the first account, then, matches two processes at once: the formation of the human head in the womb, and the formation of the world. This is fitting. If the Tabernacle is both a miniature person and a miniature world, and if a person is a miniature world, one might expect the order of its making to follow the making of both.

Last revised 15 November 2026