Conclusion
We began with a puzzle. The first account of the Tabernacle presents its parts in an order unlike any other: the ark, the table and the menorah before there is a building to hold them, then the building, then the outer altar, and only at the end, after the clothing and consecration of the priests, the incense altar, which stood beside the table and the menorah.
To understand the order, we first asked what the Tabernacle represents. The picture of a house explained only part of it. The tradition that it is a model of the world explained more: the earth, the seas, the trees, the air, the heavenly bodies and the hidden world of the spirit, arranged from the entrance inward. The sages’ teaching that a person is a miniature world led us to compare the Tabernacle to a human being, and the comparison proved close, vessel for organ, above all in the head. Other peoples have thought of their sanctuaries as bodies, but we know of no other sanctuary whose furnishings correspond, one by one, to the organs of the head, arranged as those organs are arranged.
With that foundation, the puzzle of the order has an answer. The first account follows the order in which a human head is formed in the womb: the brain, then the eyes growing out of it, then the head, then the mouth, and finally the nose, separated from the mouth only after a long interval. It also follows the order in which the world was formed: the plan, then the stars, then the sun and the planets, then the earth, and last the atmosphere in its present form. Much of this could not have been known in the ancient world. The earliest stages of the embryo are too small to be seen without a microscope, and the ancient authorities who tried to describe them disagreed with one another; one of them said plainly that the order could not be known, because no one could see it. The history of the stars and of the earth’s atmosphere was discovered only in the last century.
But the chapter has shown more than the solution to a puzzle. We found that the Tabernacle is built on a pattern of five and two: five primary vessels and an auxiliary pair, arranged one, two, one, one, with the pair attached to the fourth. We found the same pattern in the head, in the torso and in the body as a whole, with the main pattern of five continuing down to the fingers and toes. We found it in the five parts of Genesis and in the five books of the Torah, in the history the Torah tells, and in the arrangement of its laws. And we found that it is the pattern described by the kabbalah in its teaching of the sefirot.
The Critics’ Theory
Now consider what this means for the critics’ theory. On that theory, the overall structure of the Torah was planned by no one. It emerged when a redactor joined together documents that had none of that structure, written by different authors over several centuries. The plan of the Tabernacle is the work of one of those authors, the Priestly writer, and many critics hold that the Tabernacle he describes was never built at all, an ideal sanctuary that existed only on the page. And the human body was designed by no author whatever. Yet these three things, the redactor’s patchwork, the Priestly writer’s imagined sanctuary and the human body, share a single structure. The critics’ theory gives no reason why they should. On its own terms, they have nothing to do with one another.
The critic may reply that the final shaping of the Torah was itself the work of priestly circles, so that the author of the Tabernacle and the shaper of the whole belonged to the same school. But the structure runs through material the critics assign to other sources, the stories of the patriarchs among them, and we have seen that the Priestly passages are bound by their very words to the text around them. And no school of writers, however learned, can account for a match with the anatomy of the human body and the stages of its formation in the womb.
The critic may also reply that the pattern is in the eye of the beholder, found because it was sought. That is a fair challenge, and it is why so much of what we have found rests on divisions that the text itself marks out: the separate speech in which the basin is commanded, the units of text into which the laws are divided, the tradition that the book of Numbers is three books in one. The pattern is not imposed on the Torah from outside. It is there, marked by the Torah’s own divisions, for anyone who reads it with care.
None of this is proof. One may always propose that the correspondences are coincidences, or that some other explanation will yet be found. But consider the authors whom the critics imagine. However much learning the critics allow them, they were men of their own time, sharing the knowledge and the beliefs of the ancient Near East. They wrote separately, without a common plan, and their work was joined together by editors whose concern was to preserve what they had received. Such authors would not have conceived of the Tabernacle as a model of the human being and of the world. They could not have arranged the account of its making to follow the formation of a child in the womb, because they could not have known that order. And they could not have given their separate documents a single structure, shared with the sanctuary and with the human body, that none of them knew existed.
The kabbalists did not point out what we have found here, at least not in the way we have laid it out. But what we have found is consistent with their teachings in a detailed and unexpected way, as one would expect if those teachings have deep roots in the Torah itself, as the tradition has always maintained. At the very least, the Torah is not the work the critics’ theory describes. Its structure, the plan of its sanctuary and the design of the human being appear to rest on one foundation, and the simplest explanation of a single foundation is a single source.