Chapter 28: Conclusion, section 1 of 6 Overview of chapter 28 Book contents Previous Next

What This Book Has Shown

We began by asking whether the Hebrew Bible is relevant, and along the way we have looked at it from many angles. It is time to gather together what we have found.

The Torah states a plan and a purpose for creation. The world was made to be a place of blessing, in which human beings, by choosing good, would bring that blessing about. The opening chapters of Genesis tell how this plan failed. The first attempt ended in the Garden of Eden, when man lost the life he had been given there. A second beginning, with the generations that followed, ended in violence and corruption, and then in the Flood. Even the world rebuilt after the Flood soon went astray, at Babel. The sins of these chapters, we saw, follow the order of the second tablet of the Ten Commandments, one after another. And their result is curse. The word “cursed” appears five times in the first eleven chapters of Genesis: on the serpent, on the ground, on Cain, again on the ground in the naming of Noah, and on Canaan. When God then calls Abraham, His first words to him use the word “bless” five times: “and I will bless you, and make your name great; and be a blessing. And I will bless those who bless you … and in you all the families of the earth will be blessed” (Gen 12:2–3). Since the failure had brought curse, the restoration had to bring blessing. That is why a chosen nation was needed: a people charged with the task of bringing the world back to the state of blessing for which it was made.

We saw next that this purpose governs the structure of the Torah. The five books describe the history of the chosen nation in five stages, and those stages correspond to five principles, from the most basic recognition that others exist to the unity that comes when each accepts his role. The story is told in steps that match the purpose, and the Torah serves as a blueprint for the history that follows it, so that later history unfolds in the same way. Law appears where it drives the story forward: in the first part of each of the first four books, the narrative is interrupted by law, and where the people sin, progress halts.

We saw that the structure of the Torah is intricate and, to a large degree, self-similar. A single organizing principle is applied again and again, at every level of the text: the five books, the five parts of Genesis, the five sections of the story of Abraham that match the five promises made to him, the five categories of law. We argued that this is consistent with a basic idea of the kabbalistic tradition, and that the Jewish holidays reproduce the same structure, so that the calendar itself traces the flow of history year by year.

We saw that each book has its own theme or set of themes, and that material is distributed among the books so that each piece lies in the book whose theme it serves, even when chronology would have placed it elsewhere. The dedication of the Tabernacle is the clearest example. Its setting up, the consecration of the priests, and the offerings of the tribal princes all took place at the same time, yet the Torah divides the account among three books, Exodus, Leviticus and Numbers, each part in the book whose subject it belongs to.

We then turned from the large scale to the smallest details: the words the Torah uses. We found that they are chosen with extraordinary precision, and that they act as threads, or glue, binding passages of text to one another. Words of the same root, or with closely related letters, recur in ways that link one passage to another. Sometimes the Torah itself points the link out, as with Babel and the “confounding” of language; far more often it does not. A statistical test showed that these connections are too frequent and too concentrated to be the work of chance.

We used these connections to examine the passages that biblical critics assign to the Priestly source, P, in Genesis. Time after time those passages proved to be bound by their words to the surrounding text, which the critics assign to J or JE: the chiefs and kings of Edom, the sons of Keturah and of Nahor, the purchase of the cave of Machpelah, the table of nations, the Flood. The P passages are not independent insertions. They are part and parcel of the narrative around them.

We showed that these connections also join distant parts of the Torah, across books and across texts that the critics assign to different authors. The story of Joseph and his brothers, the law of the heifer whose neck is broken, and the law of the red heifer are linked by rare words that occur together almost nowhere else, in a chain that runs from Genesis through Numbers to Deuteronomy.

We showed, too, that later books of the Bible connect back to the Torah in the same way. The song of Deborah echoes the song at the Red Sea. The story of Gideon, and the book of Judges as a whole, mirror the book of Exodus. Samuel, Ruth, Ecclesiastes, the Psalms and Isaiah each draw on the Torah’s words and phrases. Their authors wrote with the Torah before them, and they treated it as the book by which events were to be understood.

Even single letters, we found, can matter. The name Sisera, spelled out in letters at equal intervals, appears in its most compact form in the Song of the Sea, the very passage to which the book of Judges ties his defeat. Such a finding means something only in a text whose every letter is known, and the Torah has been copied with a faithfulness that no other ancient text can match.

In the last part of the book we turned to the fundamental questions. The Bible’s relevance depends on whether God exists. There is no proof, and in Jewish thought there should be none, but the foundation of belief is the revelation at Sinai, witnessed by an entire nation. Science, we saw, has not made God unnecessary: the laws of nature were finely set from the first moment, and the origin of life and the great leaps in its history remain unexplained. And the Torah’s accounts of long lives and of creation are not as far from the modern picture as they are often thought to be.

Finally, we returned to the Tabernacle with a different question: not why the account of its dedication is divided among three books, but what kind of building it is, and what makes it a fitting resting place for the Divine Presence. We found that it is a model of the world: its parts correspond, from the entrance inward, to the earth, the seas, the trees, the air, the heavenly bodies and the world of the spirit. It is also a model of the human being. Its five primary vessels correspond one by one to the five main organs of the head, arranged as those organs are arranged, with the skull holding them and the mouth outside it. The same pattern, five main members with a pair attached to the fourth, recurs in the torso and in the body as a whole, and the pattern of five continues down to the fingers and toes. It is the pattern the kabbalah describes in its teaching of the sefirot, and the same pattern we found in the structure of Genesis, of the Torah as a whole, and of the history the Torah describes. The first account of the Tabernacle presents its parts in an order unlike every other account, one that has long puzzled readers. That order follows, step by step, the sequence in which the organs of the human head are formed in the womb, and also the sequence in which the world itself was formed. Much of this could not have been known in the ancient world.

Last revised 15 November 2026