Chapter 28: Conclusion, section 2 of 6 Overview of chapter 28 Book contents Previous Next

Two Pictures

Taken together, everything we have seen gives a single, clear impression, and it is exactly the impression the tradition has always held. The Torah looks like one unified work. It was revered by those who came after it, and later authors referred to it constantly, by allusion, as a text they knew intimately and held in the highest regard. It shows genius and artistry throughout: careful organization on the largest scale, care in the smallest detail, and a great many surprises and touches of cleverness that reveal themselves only to the attentive reader.

That impression seems wholly incompatible with the way biblical critics understand the Torah. Let us look at their view more closely.

According to the theory that has dominated academic study of the Bible for nearly a century and a half, usually called the Documentary Hypothesis and given its classic form by the German scholar Julius Wellhausen in 1878, the Torah is not one book but several. It was assembled from four main sources, each written by a different author or school, in a different place and at a different time, and later cut apart and pasted together by editors.

The order of writing, in the classic version, runs as follows. The oldest source, called J because it uses the divine name YHWH (spelled with a J in German), is usually placed in the kingdom of Judah in the ninth or tenth century BCE. The second, E, so called because it refers to God as Elohim before the revelation of the divine name to Moses, is thought to have been written somewhat later in the northern kingdom of Israel. The third, D, is essentially the book of Deuteronomy, dated to the seventh century BCE and usually connected with the scroll found in the Temple in the reign of Josiah. The last, P, the Priestly source, is placed during or after the Babylonian exile, in the sixth or fifth century BCE. It contains the creation account of Genesis 1, the genealogies, much of the Flood story, and most of the laws of the Tabernacle, the sacrifices and the priesthood.

How much did each author know of the others? Here the critics’ views have varied. In the classic theory, J and E were written independently. D knew the combined JE narrative and built on it. P, too, knew the earlier material and in part wrote as a response to it, offering its own version of events. More recently, a group of scholars known as the Neo-Documentarians has argued that the sources were wholly independent, each a complete and separate account, so that P did not depend on J at all. Others have gone in the opposite direction, holding that P was never a separate document but was written directly around the existing text, as additions to it. Many scholars, especially in Europe, now doubt that E ever existed, and some doubt that J was ever a continuous document. The theory has many versions, and its defenders do not agree among themselves.

What, then, did the editor, or redactor, do? In the classic view, a redactor first combined J and E, keeping what he wanted of each and leaving out duplicates. Later editors added D, and finally P, producing the Torah as we know it, perhaps in the time of Ezra. The redactor is credited with fitting the pieces together and adding occasional words or verses to smooth the joins. Yet he is also held to have left in place the duplications and inconsistencies that critics regard as the evidence of separate sources: two accounts of creation, two interwoven accounts of the Flood, and so on. The Neo-Documentarians go further still. In their view the compiler cut almost nothing and added almost nothing, preserving each source nearly whole and simply interleaving them.

The critics’ Torah, then, is a patchwork: the work of several authors who did not share a single plan, written over several centuries, and joined by editors whose main concern was to preserve what they had received. The next question is whether that picture can account for what we have found.

Last revised 15 November 2026