Biblical Criticism
Alongside science came the scholarly enterprise known as biblical criticism. It must be understood in broad terms, because its details will occupy much of this book.
Biblical criticism is, at its core, a method of reading the Bible against itself. Its evidence comes almost entirely from the text: changes in the names of God, repetitions, apparent contradictions, and differences of style and vocabulary. From these internal features critics reconstructed hidden earlier documents and the editors who supposedly combined them. No manuscript of any of these documents has ever been found, no ancient writer mentions them, and no tradition remembers them. Their existence, contents, and dates are inferred from the finished text alone.
In its classical form, given definitive shape by Julius Wellhausen in 1878, the theory reached these conclusions. Moses did not write the Torah. It was assembled over centuries from several independent documents. Much of its law came late, after the Babylonian exile, not at the beginning of Israel’s history. Its accounts of the patriarchs, the Exodus, and Sinai are legend and theology, not history. Prophecies that appear to foretell events were written after the events. Israel’s religion evolved gradually from something primitive into monotheism, which the Bible then projected back onto earlier times.
The theory’s wide acceptance cannot be explained by its logic alone. It appeared when the educated world was already turning away from traditional religion. Darwin’s book and Wellhausen’s appeared within twenty years of each other, and both told a story of gradual development without divine intervention. Criticism allowed liberal believers to keep the Bible as a human record of religious progress while giving up its claim to be revelation. For others it confirmed that the Bible could be set aside entirely. It met a need of the age, and it became orthodoxy in the universities long before it had been seriously tested.
The theory also rests on an assumption that is seldom stated plainly. As a matter of method, historical study must explain events by natural causes alone. Within that framework God cannot speak to Moses, prophets cannot foretell the future, and the Torah cannot be what it claims to be. This does not mean every critic was an unbeliever; many were devout. But the method excludes God as an explanation from the start, and the consequences are severe. The Torah repeatedly states that God spoke these words to Moses. If He did not, that claim is untrue. If prophecies were written after the fact, they present themselves as something they are not. Some early critics said so openly and called Deuteronomy a “pious fraud.” And the generations who accepted these books as revelation, lived by them, and preserved them at great cost must have been deceived.
The theory grew up, moreover, in a scholarly world that thought little of the people who produced the Bible. The influential French scholar Ernest Renan held that the “Semitic mind” had given the world monotheism but lacked the capacity for philosophy, science, and creative imagination. Wellhausen portrayed the religion of the later biblical period as a decline into empty legalism. Others argued that the Bible’s best ideas had simply been borrowed from Babylon. On this view the Hebrews were compilers, not artists. No one expected a work of genuine unity from them, so whatever seemed rough in the text was put down to clumsy editing rather than to deliberate design.
Taken to its conclusions, the theory makes the Torah a book composed in a way unlike any other known work. Editors are supposed to have cut documents into fragments, sometimes alternating between sources within a single verse. They are supposed to have kept contradictions they could easily have removed, and yet produced a narrative that readers for thousands of years took to be a single, coherent whole. Wherever a passage does not fit the pattern, a “redactor” is called in to explain it, which makes the theory nearly impossible to disprove.
The theory nevertheless spread beyond the universities. Encyclopedias presented it to the public, and the major Protestant churches came to accept it. The Catholic Church resisted at first, but in 1943 Pope Pius XII encouraged Catholic scholars to use historical and literary methods, and a Vatican document of 1993 called the historical-critical method “indispensable.”
Much has changed in the century and a half since Wellhausen. The scholarly consensus has broken down, and critics no longer agree on the number, extent, or dates of the sources, or even on whether independent sources existed at all. Literary scholars have shown that repetition, variation, and apparent inconsistency are often deliberate techniques of a sophisticated art. Several of the theory’s foundational criteria have been weakened or abandoned. And scholars have openly acknowledged the theological prejudices that shaped the original reconstruction. Yet the basic premise remains. Within the academic method the Torah must be a human composition from long after the events it describes, because the alternative has been ruled out in advance.