A Failure of Gratitude
That the root of the sin was ingratitude can be seen in several ways.
When God confronted Adam, he answered, “The woman whom Thou gave to be with me, she gave me of the tree” (3:12). The sages saw in these words an expression of ingratitude: Adam blamed the very gift God had given him (Avodah Zarah 5b, cited by Rashi on this verse).
The first sin after Eden was not, in fact, the murder of Abel. It was Cain’s offering. Abel brought “the firstlings of his flock and of their fat” (4:4); Cain brought simply “of the fruit of the ground” (4:3). Rashi, following the Midrash, says Cain brought produce of inferior quality. If you truly wish to thank someone, you do not give him your leftovers.
The words the Torah uses for Cain’s offering are significant: pri ha-adamah, “the fruit of the ground.” In this exact form, the phrase appears elsewhere in the Torah only in Deuteronomy’s law of the first fruits, bikkurim; related forms, such as “the fruit of your ground,” appear several times in Deuteronomy. There a farmer is commanded to bring “the first of all the fruit of the ground” (26:2) to the Temple, with a declaration of thanks to God for the land He has given (26:10). The first fruits included both grain and the fruit of trees (Mishnah Bikkurim 1:3), recalling both Cain’s offering and the fruit of the tree in Eden.
The First and Last Laws
The law of first fruits is the second-to-last law in the great legal code of Deuteronomy. The last is the declaration a farmer makes after giving his tithes to the Levite, the stranger, the orphan, and the widow, ending with a prayer that God bless His people and the land He has given them (26:12–15). Both concluding laws are expressions of gratitude for what God gives us. The first sin after Eden was a failure of gratitude, an offering of pri ha-adamah. The last laws of the code are acts of gratitude, an offering of pri ha-adamah.
The first laws given to Israel point the same way. Rashi, in his very first comment on the Torah, notes that the first commandment given to Israel as a nation comes in Exodus 12, the chapter of the Passover laws. The Passover laws are built around the seder, which is above all an expression of gratitude for liberation from bondage. The law requires that the story of the Exodus be retold every year, and the seder concludes with Hallel, songs of praise to God.
And at the heart of the seder is the very declaration of the first fruits. The Mishnah (Pesachim 10:4) prescribes that the Exodus be told by expounding the passage the farmer recites when bringing bikkurim, beginning “An Aramean sought to destroy my father” (Deuteronomy 26:5), and the Haggadah discusses it phrase by phrase. The first laws given to Israel are thus tied directly to the last laws of Deuteronomy’s code.
When a work begins and ends on the same theme, it suggests that the theme runs through everything in between. The ultimate aim of the Torah is to repair the damage done in Eden. The sin was ingratitude. The repair is gratitude.