Sin: What Arrests Progress
If law is the driving force of progress, sin is what arrests it. Sin is a violation of law, so it tends to appear after law has been given, in the fourth or fifth subunit of a unit of text rather than in the first three. The pattern holds at several levels.
Genesis. In the first part of Genesis, the sin of Adam and Eve in the garden forms the fourth subunit. It comes immediately after the first command was given (“of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, you shall not eat of it,” 2:17). The fifth subunit follows with the five sins of the generations from Cain to Babel. As we have seen, those five sins violate the commandments of the second tablet in order.
In the story of Abraham, the fourth section opens with a sinful region, Sodom and the cities of the plain, and their destruction (chs. 18-19).
In the book as a whole, the pattern is clearer still. The Torah records little or no improper conduct on the part of the first two patriarchs, Abraham and Isaac. With Jacob, whose history forms the fourth part of Genesis, this changes:
- Jacob’s own conduct. He took his father’s blessing from his brother by deception, and the Torah shows that he suffered for it. The deceiver was deceived in turn: “why then have you beguiled me?” he asks Laban after the substitution of Leah for Rachel (29:25). The verb (root R-M-H) is the same one Isaac used of Jacob himself: “Your brother came with guile” (27:35). Laban went on to change his wages “ten times” (31:7, 41).
- Esau. He resolved to kill him: “then I will kill my brother Jacob” (27:41). The Torah does not explicitly condemn or punish this intent, but it is sinful nonetheless.
- Others. Jacob’s history also includes the violation of Dinah and the slaughter at Shechem (ch. 34), and Reuben’s act with Bilhah (35:22).
The fifth part, Joseph and his brothers, is full of sin:
- the brothers’ intent to kill Joseph: “come now therefore, and let us kill him” (37:20);
- the kidnapping and sale of Joseph: “for indeed I was stolen away out of the land of the Hebrews” (40:15);
- the sins of Er and Onan (38:7-10);
- the attempt of Potiphar’s wife to seduce Joseph (ch. 39).
Sin in Exodus, Leviticus and Numbers
Exodus. In the first part of Exodus, the sins appear in the fourth subunit: the complaints over water at Marah, over food in the wilderness of Sin, and again over water at Massah and Meribah (15:22-17:7). They come directly after law. At Marah, just before the people’s complaints are answered, “there He made for them a statute and an ordinance, and there He tested them” (15:25). Law is given, and then it is tested.
The great sin of the book, the golden calf (chs. 32-34), falls in the book’s fourth part. It is framed on both sides by law concerning the Sabbath:
- before it, the Sabbath as “a sign between Me and the children of Israel for ever” (31:12-17);
- after it, the Sabbath again, as the first instruction given before the building of the Tabernacle (35:1-3).
Each of these is separated from the narrative only by a closed break, which binds law and sin into a single unit. The Sabbath, as we have seen, belongs to the fourth level.
There is further evidence that the calf is a fourth-level sin. The laws that God gives when the covenant is renewed after it (34:17-26) largely repeat the fourth section of the mishpatim (23:12-19), some of them almost word for word:
- the Sabbath;
- the three pilgrimage festivals;
- “none shall appear before Me empty”;
- the prohibition of offering blood with leaven or leaving a festival offering until morning;
- the first fruits;
- “You shall not boil a kid in its mother’s milk.”
The covenant is restored at the level at which it was broken.
Leviticus. The death of Nadav and Avihu does not fit the pattern; it falls in the second subunit of the first part of the book. But the only other sin recorded in Leviticus, the blasphemer (24:10-23), falls in the book’s fourth part, as we noted earlier.
Numbers. The fourth book contains more sinful conduct than any other: the complaints, the craving for meat, Miriam and Aaron’s speech against Moses, the spies, the man gathering wood on the Sabbath, Korach, the waters of Meribah, the serpents, Baal Peor. These are concentrated in the book’s second and fourth parts. That many of them fall in the second part does not contradict the pattern. Numbers as a whole stands at the fourth level of the Torah, and the whole book is therefore the natural place for sin. That the fourth book of the Torah is the book of sin is itself the pattern on the largest scale.