The LORD of Hosts
A second name of God tells the same story from the other direction. The title YHWH Tzevaot, “the LORD of hosts,” first appears in 1 Samuel 1:3, where Elkanah goes up “to worship and to sacrifice to the LORD of hosts in Shiloh.” From then on it is used more than two hundred and fifty times. It appears in Samuel, Kings, and the Psalms, and above all in the prophets: Isaiah, Jeremiah, Haggai, Zechariah, and Malachi. In the first seven books of the Bible, Genesis through Judges, it never occurs.
The ideas behind the title were there all along. The Israelites leave Egypt as “the hosts of the LORD” (Exod 12:41), and God calls them “My hosts” (7:4). Joshua meets “the captain of the host of the LORD” (Josh 5:14). The words were available, but the divine title formed from them does not appear.
Some critics have argued that the late writers avoided the title for theological reasons. But a writer living among prophets who used it hundreds of times would be expected to let it slip in somewhere. And the absence extends through Joshua and Judges, books the theory places close to the Torah’s own editors. It ends exactly where the narrative itself places the title’s first use, at the sanctuary of Shiloh. That is an odd place for a theological avoidance to stop, but a natural one for the historical beginning of a title.
El Shaddai
The name El Shaddai has the opposite distribution. As a joined name it appears six times: Genesis 17:1, 28:3, 35:11, 43:14, 48:3, and Exodus 6:3. All six are speech: God speaking of Himself, or Isaac and Jacob speaking of God. So the name also fits the narrator’s rule. After Exodus 6 the two words never appear together in the Torah. They appear only split between the two halves of a line of poetry: “By the God [El] of your father, who will help you, and by the Almighty [Shaddai], who will bless you” (Gen 49:25). Balaam’s poems split them in the same way (Num 24:4, 16), and so do many verses of Job. In Psalm 91:1 Shaddai stands beside another ancient name, Elyon, “the Most High.” Shaddai alone appears in Ruth, Isaiah, Joel, and Ezekiel.
There is one exception outside the Torah. In Ezekiel 10:5 the sound of the cherubs’ wings is “like the voice of God Almighty [El Shaddai] when He speaks.” Ezekiel invokes the ancient name in a comparison, and in 1:24, describing the same sound, he uses Shaddai alone.
So El Shaddai belongs to the age of the patriarchs, as Exodus 6:3 says it does, and the LORD of hosts belongs to the age that begins with Shiloh and Samuel. The two names move in opposite directions, and each matches the Torah’s own account of the order of events.
What the Names Show
The evidence of this chapter supports two separate conclusions, and they should be kept apart.
The first concerns unity. The narrator’s rule holds across the whole Torah, through material the critics divide among several sources. Its only exception, in the garden of Eden, is placed exactly where its teaching belongs, and the one compound name in speech, Moses’ words to Pharaoh, makes the same point. In the Joseph story, the name that gave E its identity turns out to belong to the characters, not to a source. The test on which the documentary theory was founded, read correctly, points to one author following one consistent practice.
The second concerns date. Three separate markers line up with the Torah’s own chronology. Names containing the divine name are absent from the Torah, rare in Joshua and Judges, and common under the monarchy. The title LORD of hosts begins at Shiloh. El Shaddai belongs to the patriarchs. Any one of these might be explained as a late writer’s deliberate choice. All three together, kept perfectly and without a single slip into the habits of a later age, are much harder to explain that way. As in a detective story, any single clue may be a coincidence, but several independent clues pointing in the same direction are hard to dismiss. They do not by themselves prove when the Torah was written. But they are what one would expect of a book written in the age it describes, and they are not what one would expect of a book composed centuries later.