What Science Does and Does Not Say
Set the Bible aside for a moment and ask a different question. Is there anything in science or philosophy that shows that God does not exist, or even makes His existence unlikely? Many people assume there is. It is worth looking at what the claim actually amounts to, beginning with science.
Science, by its definition, is the study of the physical world. As it is practiced today, it explains what happens in nature only in terms of other things in nature: matter, energy, forces and the laws that govern them. It proceeds, in practice, as though nothing else were at work. It does this not because it has discovered that nothing else exists, but because this is the only way it can do its job. The aim of science is to find the regular laws by which the physical world operates. If at some point a scientist said, “Here God intervened,” the inquiry would stop, and whatever followed would no longer be science as the word is understood. Science does not look for what cannot be seen, measured or touched. That does not rule out the existence of God, or of a spiritual realm of any kind. It simply leaves them aside. A map of roads that shows no rivers has not proven that there are no rivers; it was not drawn to show them.
Scientists sometimes go further and say that we no longer need God to explain anything, that the world can be understood without reference to Him. We will look at this claim more closely shortly. For now, notice what kind of claim it is. It does not say that we know God does not exist. It is a reply to an old argument, one that held that we know God exists because there is no other way to account for what happens in the physical world: the motion of the planets, the coming of the rain, the variety of living things. Some of those old explanations have indeed been replaced, and no one doubts it. But to say that certain events once credited directly to God now have natural explanations is a far narrower statement than to say that God is unnecessary altogether. As we shall see, the facts support the first statement much better than the second.
Some scientists, finally, make a broader claim still: that nothing exists except the physical, except what can in principle be investigated by science. This is a statement of opinion, not a scientific finding. It is not clear what kind of claim it is meant to be, or how it could ever be shown to be true. No experiment could establish it, since any experiment can only examine the physical things it was designed to examine. A net with a two-inch mesh will never catch a fish smaller than two inches, but no fisherman would conclude from his catch that such fish do not exist. The claim that only the physical is real is not a result of science. It is a belief about science, held by some who practice it, and it stands or falls on grounds that science itself cannot supply.
Nor is it clear that science must stay away from such questions altogether. Science deals constantly with things no one has seen. Dark matter, which makes up most of the matter in the universe, has never been observed directly; it is known only from its pull on the things we can see. What science requires is not that a thing be visible, but that it leave some trace that can be measured. Some have looked for such traces of a realm beyond the physical. Researchers have tested whether prayer for the sick, unknown to the patients, has any measurable effect; some smaller studies reported benefits, while the largest, published in 2006, found none. The psychiatrist Ian Stevenson of the University of Virginia spent some forty years investigating young children who described memories of a previous life, and in many cases the details they gave were found to match the life of a real person who had died. Others have studied the reports of people who, close to death, describe watching from above as doctors worked to revive them. None of this proves anything, and all of it has its critics. But it shows that claims about a reality beyond the physical are not necessarily beyond the reach of evidence. To rule them out in advance, on the ground that only the physical can be real, is not a conclusion of science but an assumption made before the inquiry has begun.
What Philosophy Does and Does Not Say
The same holds for philosophy. All the philosophy in the world cannot declare that God does not exist. It can ask questions that deserve answers, and it can raise doubts that a thoughtful believer should face. But no philosophical argument has ever shown that the existence of God is impossible.
The question raised most often, by philosophers and by ordinary people alike, concerns good and evil. If God is good, why does evil exist? Why do the innocent suffer, and why do the wicked so often prosper?
As we saw in the early chapters of this book, this happens to be the very first question the Hebrew Bible takes up. The opening chapters of Genesis explain how the world, created good, came to be filled with violence and wrongdoing, and why the remedy required a nation charged with a mission. Earlier in this chapter we saw the other half of that answer: the world is made so that human beings can truly choose, and a world in which good can be chosen is necessarily a world in which evil can be chosen too. Not everyone will be satisfied with this answer. Many people do not accept it, and it is not offered here as though it settled every case of suffering.
Nor does the Bible pretend the question is easy. It puts the question in the mouths of its greatest figures. Abraham, pleading for Sodom, asks, “Shall not the Judge of all the earth do justly?” (Gen 18:25). Jeremiah asks, “Why does the way of the wicked prosper?” (Jer 12:1). The whole book of Job is given over to a righteous man who suffers without cause and demands to know why. None of these men concluded that God does not exist. They argued with Him, which is something one does only with someone who is there.
This points to the deeper answer. Judaism, as we have seen, rests on a historical event, not on a philosophical argument. If that event occurred, then we may ask as many questions about it as we like, and none of them will undo it. A person may decide that he cannot accept a God who permits suffering, and may choose to turn away from Him. That is a choice. But it is not a disproof. It amounts to saying, “I do not like what God has done, so I will not take Him into account.” It says something about the person’s response; it says nothing about whether God exists.
In any case, a great many people, including many who have known terrible suffering, have faced these questions and have not rejected God because of them. The questions are real. Nothing in them compels anyone to conclude that there is no God.
Why Science Needs a Closer Look
These philosophical questions have been debated for centuries, indeed for thousands of years, and a vast amount has been written about them. This book will not try to add to that literature. A reader who finds them troubling is unlikely to accept any argument offered here as the last word on the subject, and rightly so. These are questions each person must investigate for himself, with the help of the many thinkers, ancient and modern, who have wrestled with them.
One point, however, should be made clear. The weight of these questions depends on whether there is evidence for God from elsewhere. If there is good reason to believe that God exists, and that He revealed Himself at Sinai, then the questions remain and must be faced, but they are questions asked within belief, as Abraham, Jeremiah and Job asked them. If there is no such evidence, then they may add to a doubt that already exists. On their own, they are not strong grounds for concluding that there is no God. They test a belief; they do not decide it.
Science is a different matter. Over the past century and a half, discoveries have been made that changed, often dramatically, the way people look at the world, at their place in it, and at the question of God. The age and size of the universe, the origin of the earth, the development of life, the workings of the human mind: on each of these, modern science has given answers that many people believe leave no room for God. Whether they are right cannot be decided without at least a general look at what has been discovered and what it does and does not show. That is the subject of the next chapter. It is not possible to treat it in great detail, but it cannot be passed over.