Why Some Things Are Commanded and Others Are Not
We saw earlier that, if light was created first, the opening verses may serve to tell us that the earth existed and in what state, without a command of its own. There is a further reason why no command was needed. If the light of the first day is the burst of energy with which the universe began, Everything that followed automatically from that beginning would need no separate command. The stars and galaxies, and the planets that formed around many stars, arose from the laws already built into the first moment. The universe, we now know, is full of planets. The earth, as a rocky body orbiting a star, is in that sense nothing unusual. It needed no special word to bring it into being.
Look now at what the Torah does describe with a command. In the first chapter of Genesis, God speaks before each new stage of creation: light; the firmament dividing the waters; the gathering of the waters so that dry land appears; vegetation; the lights in the heavens, set “for signs, and for seasons, and for days and years” (Gen 1:14); the creatures of the water and the birds; the animals of the land; and finally human beings. There is a common thread running through all of them. The Torah does not tell us that God made the mountains, or the rocks, or the molten core deep within the earth. Every command is concerned in one way or another with life. Light is the basis of everything. Water is essential to life, and so is the proper division between sea and land. The sun and moon, whatever else they are, are described here in terms of their role for life on earth: they mark the seasons, the days and the years. And from there on, every command concerns living things directly.
Notice too that each of these things is, in a sense, not automatic. As we saw earlier, a universe with the right laws produces stars and planets more or less as a matter of course. It does not, as far as anyone has shown, produce a planet with the right amount of water, the right atmosphere and the right conditions for life. And even once life exists, nothing in it requires that it produce fish, birds, land animals and human beings. Each of these is a step that cannot be taken for granted. The earth’s geological features, by contrast, the ones that are hidden from human sight, such as its inner structure, play no part in the account. The Torah describes the world as it concerns the human beings who live in it.
The Mishnah asks a well-known question: “With ten utterances the world was created. What does this teach us? Could it not have been created with one utterance?” (Avot 5:1). Its answer is a moral one: the world was made with many utterances so that those who destroy it bear a greater guilt, and those who sustain it earn a greater reward. The question is perfectly sound. God could certainly have created everything with a single utterance. He could have set the conditions of the beginning so precisely that everything, life included, would follow on its own without any further word. Yet He chose not to. The utterances come at the turning points, at just those places where, by the measure of nature alone, the next step was not to be expected. There God spoke again, and through those added words we are taught how much He invested in the world, and therefore how much is at stake in what we do with it.