Miracles
Miracles in general present a great difficulty for the modern mind. To a reader raised on science, the miracles of the Bible seem simply impossible: things that cannot happen, and therefore did not.
A surprising reply can be given. Modern science, in a certain sense, believes in miracles more than any religious person does.
What is a miracle? It is an event that cannot be explained by natural causes. Consider again what we saw earlier about the origin of life. When one tries to estimate the likelihood that even the simplest living cell could have assembled itself by chance from non-living chemicals, the numbers that result are so incredibly small that no natural process, given all the time and material in the universe, could be expected to produce it. An event that improbable is, by any ordinary standard, a miracle. Many biologists would strongly object to this. To them, life must arise easily, and the proof is that it appeared on earth so quickly. But no one has shown why it should be easy, and the raw numbers point the other way. The same is true of the universe itself. A universe that came into existence on its own, with its laws and its constants set precisely enough to permit stars, planets and life, would be the greatest miracle of all.
The usual answer, as we saw in the previous chapter, is the multiverse: countless universes, among which we happen to live in one of the rare ones where things worked out. The improbability is real; it comes from calculation. The proposed answer is pure speculation. To meet a real difficulty with an explanation that can never be tested is to appeal, in effect, to something beyond nature. And that is very close to what we mean by a miracle.
The believer, by contrast, has an explanation that is reasonable even by the standards of evidence. There is no evidence at all for another universe. For God there is at least some evidence, and of a kind that can be weighed. There are the words of the prophets, who thousands of years ago foretold that the Jewish people would be scattered among the nations and would, at the end of days, return to their land: “then the LORD your God will turn your captivity… and will return and gather you from all the peoples among whom the LORD your God has scattered you” (Deut 30:3). Most of all there is the Torah’s account, which Jews have held to be accurate for thousands of years, of an entire nation hearing the voice of God and taking upon itself His commandments because of what it heard. For one who believes in God, creation and the origin of life are not miracles in the sense of inexplicable events. They have a cause, and the cause is God. It is the one who believes only in the physical world who must accept that it all came about by miracle.
The miracles of the Bible, moreover, are surprisingly unlike what most people imagine. Apart from creation itself, they are almost never a matter of something appearing out of nothing. In nearly every case the miracle works through physical things. Consider what is perhaps the greatest miracle recorded in the Torah, the parting of the Red Sea. In the familiar film version the waters simply split apart in an instant. The Torah tells it differently: “and the LORD caused the sea to go back by a strong east wind all the night, and made the sea dry land” (Exod 14:21). The miracle lay in the timing and the force of the wind, not necessarily, in the words of the Torah, in a suspension of the laws of nature. When the people craved meat in the wilderness, “a wind went out from the LORD, and brought across quails from the sea” (Num 11:31). When the prophet Elisha helped a poor widow, he did not create oil from nothing. He asked her what she had in the house, and she had a single pot of oil. From that pot she filled vessel after vessel until no empty vessels remained (2 Kings 4:1–7). There had to be some oil, and borrowed vessels, to begin with.
Nachmanides makes this a general principle: God does not multiply miracles needlessly, and where a natural means is available, the Torah’s miracles work through it (Nachmanides on Gen 6:19).
Is a miracle possible at all? For one who believes in God, there is no reason why not. The laws of nature are His laws, and He is not bound by them. The Talmud tells of Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa, whose daughter one Sabbath eve mistakenly filled the Sabbath lamp with vinegar instead of oil. He told her not to worry: “He who commanded the oil to burn will command the vinegar to burn” (Taanit 25a). And the lamp burned until the Sabbath was over.
Why Miracles Leave Room for Doubt
There is a reason the Torah’s miracles work through the physical world and are not simply magic, and it takes us back to what was said earlier about the hiddenness of God. The world, olam, is the place where God is hidden, because without that hiddenness there could be no real choice. A miracle that was wholly inexplicable, with no natural element at all, would leave no room for doubt; it would compel belief. A miracle that works through nature leaves a way out. The sea parted before the eyes of an entire people, yet it was a strong east wind, blowing all night, that drove it back. One who wished to see the hand of God could see it; one who wished to see only a remarkable storm could see that instead. The Egyptians, who had just watched the sea divide, rode straight into it after the Israelites. The miracle of the widow’s oil is harder to explain in this way, but it was not performed in public. Elisha told the widow to go into her house and “shut the door upon you and upon your sons” (2 Kings 4:4) before she began to pour. Only she and her sons, who brought her the vessels, saw what was happening. Even when God reveals His hand, He leaves room to look away.